REACTION / COMMENTARY

Michael Knowles & Matt Walsh Are Morons: Part 1

Room 9 commentary on Michael Knowles and Matt Walsh.

THE WORDS BEHIND THE VIDEO

TRANSCRIPT.

YouTube-generated captions, grouped into readable passages. These have not been human-corrected and may contain errors, especially names, punctuation, and overlapping speech. Timestamp links open the matching moment on YouTube.

64 timestamped passages

0:00 ↗

[music] [music] [music] [music]

0:41 ↗

[music] [music] [music]

1:08 ↗

[music] [music] [music] >> All right. We're here. And today

1:33 ↗

we are going to listen to a dumbass from The Daily Wire and then another dumbass from The Daily Wire. We got a Michael Knowles video and a Matt Walsh video here to take a look at and see how bad faith these guys actually are cuz there's anything I know about people from The Daily Wire, they are bad faith. Bad faith interlocutors are always the

2:00 ↗

best, are they not? Let me check some volume here. I think we're looking good. Video I audio is already working, so we're going to jump right into it. And this is a video from the Ice Coffee Hour clips. I've seen this one guy on the left his face before. Not totally sure who this dude is.

2:29 ↗

I don't know how I know these guys from somewhere, but I don't know, this popped up in my feed. I figured we'd give it a listen. And let's just kick it right off. >> My question when it comes to religion is that there are so many different religions out there and every religion believes that they are right. And so in virtue of that >> You're not necessarily >> I I I tend to think that it How do you know which one is the correct one if there are so many out there? >> necessarily. There are a lot of different theories of physics, right?

2:55 ↗

>> hearing it >> And they're they contradict one another. So, how do you know which one is right? There are a lot of different theories of evolution and if you're inclined to you know, [laughter] be really gung-ho about evolution, well, which one do you think is right? Is it >> First >> [laughter] >> No, there aren't a lot of different theories in physics or evolution that contradict each other. There are some unknowns in the quantum mechanic world. We don't have a theory

3:20 ↗

of everything that combines relativity and quantum mechanics. There's a lot we don't know. So, there are different theories to explain some of the things we don't know, but to call something like evolution like Newtonian mechanics. No, there's just Newtonian mechanics. Sorry. Like that's true. Evolution, Darwinism

3:46 ↗

there's nothing. What is that What is that? Lamarckianism? Is that Lamarck? Was that the other guy? False. Falsified 100 years ago. No. The only thing people that is changing is people are adding on to Darwin and neo-Darwinism, so on and so forth. Like what a dumb, ignorant, bad faith statement that is. And somebody's going to listen to this and just [ __ ] repeat it. Like this is not

4:12 ↗

close to the truth. I just I This is the kind of stupidness we have to deal with. This is what happens when you don't educate yourself in any type of science. And you just dive right into [ __ ] spirituality and religion. Everything people sound Everything people says sounds great.

4:39 ↗

But it was almost a century ago that Lamarckian Lamarck Lamarckism Lamarckism, I think that's what it is. I think it was Lamarck, yeah. So it'd be Lamarckism. Over a century ago it was falsified. Like what are we talking about? What a dumb thing to say. We're only 28 seconds in. 28 seconds into this video and he's already said one of the dumbest things I've ever heard in my life. >> Is it Darwin? Is it Lamarck? Is it some

5:05 ↗

newer strand of either of those? You You use your reason and you you separate fact from fiction and you >> How many How many arguments of Aquinas are we going to get in here? I'm going to go with at least two. In a 10-minute video he's going to at least bring up two um of Aquinas's five ways. >> Take You believe the more persuasive arguments and you throw out the less persuasive arguments. And that's what you do with religion when when it comes to theology. Theology is fake.

5:33 ↗

>> Yeah, but you need evidence. Michael, you need evidence to talk about anything. Like it's like discussing between the Tooth Fairy and Santa, which one is real. Like what are we talking about here? >> Faith seeking understanding. So, it's applying logic and the rigors of reason to our faith. >> about logic. >> And and religion is just simply a habit of virtue that inclines the will to give

5:59 ↗

to God what he deserves. So, we talk about multiple religions, but there's really only one religion. And we're all just trying to figure out what it is. >> But, do you believe that other >> [laughter] >> Okay. Okay. There's only one religion, we're all just trying to figure out what it is. No, we don't know that there's only one religion cuz there's no empirical

6:25 ↗

evidence for any of it. There's there's no empirical evidence for anything supernatural. We've never had any. And when we get some, then we can start talking about different theories in theology and for the supernatural. Like, it's such a dumb thing to [ __ ] say. >> sex of that religion are incorrect or are against marriage. That's what I'm talking about. [laughter] Uh yeah, I I mean

6:52 ↗

I I'm I'm Catholic. Yeah. Uh I think that's true. I think that's a true faith. So, in as much as >> the one he believes is the true faith. >> contradicts that, I think that religion is wrong. Of course, but that's you know, that's just Aristotle's non-contradiction principle, right? You can't simultaneously believe >> I love that he is trying to use logic to prove his faith. This is going to be great. >> things that are in opposition. I think even the the most atheistic person would

7:17 ↗

say that certain religions seem more plausible than other religions, you know, uh >> Yes. What would be Yes, I would say well, I would say I don't have evidence for some religions. If you ask me if I believe in God. Christian God? No. Christian God does not exist. I would I will make a hard stance on that. Jesus didn't fulfill one Messianic prophecy.

7:44 ↗

There's all these contradictions. New Testament authors manipulated, changed words. I mean, this is obvious scholarly consensus throughout academia and everything else. Like No, there's no [ __ ] way. This >> A good example of this without offending wide swath of the audience. Most people out there

8:09 ↗

would say that uh Christianity is more plausible than Scientology. Right? >> No. >> Why? >> Well, Scientology makes all these crazy claims about machines and technology. Okay. Like space aliens. Like Okay. Like kind of actually the claims you're Are you guys Scientologists? You are? I I had a feeling. >> [laughter] >> Bad example, then. Uh so, we would say that Okay, well, if Christianity is more persuasive than

8:36 ↗

Scientology, then okay, you've you've just dismissed one of >> You guys are Scientologists? Really? I don't know what This one guy, the one host on the left, I swear like I saw him in political [ __ ] I got to look him up who the [ __ ] he is, but Like No, I would say actually, I don't know much about Scientology to be honest, so I would take a very soft stance on it, but to sit here and act like Christianity is

9:01 ↗

such an obvious truth is [ __ ] mind-blowing. >> other religions. Well, how about the other ones? Do you think it's more persuasive than Islam? I do. I think that the historical >> Of course you do, Michael, cuz that's the religion you grew up in. >> claims of And and the theological claims of Christianity are are more persuasive than Islam. Okay, we got rid of that one. How about Judaism? I, you know, have great respect for my >> He just hand waves it away. Okay, we got rid of that one.

9:27 ↗

>> Jewish friends and my Muslim friends and even Scientologists, some of them. Uh but Judaism says Jesus is not who he says he is. Christianity says Jesus is who he says he is. Well, I don't know. What is it? Then one investigates this question and >> Yep, we investigate this question and we find out Jesus didn't fulfill any prophecies, not one single one. We find out the New Testament authors

9:53 ↗

made up [ __ ] We find out that nothing was even written down about Jesus until, let's be generous, 50 years after he died. We find out that Jesus lies. That's also surprising. And we find out that Jesus wants us to keep the laws of Moses until he returns. So, we should still be fulfilling those and that Paul contradicts him and tries

10:19 ↗

to get rid of that. >> And I've arrived at the conclusion that he is who he says he is. Okay, so there goes that religion. How about Buddhism? Well, all the Buddhists I know are just like liberal women in northern Westchester who wear tight pants and, you know, meditate during the So, they're not right about anything. I I can easily dismiss >> Oh my god, this guy is [ __ ] dumb. If you listen to this dude and take him seriously, I don't your brain is broke.

10:48 ↗

The hand wave away Buddhism like that. It's cuz he doesn't know anything about Buddhism. That's the problem. And in his rich-ass neighborhood, his [ __ ] neighbors who wear yoga pants get all spiritual. And he hates it. So, he hand waves away that. That's at least more of a philosophy than a theology. >> It's that religion. How about Hinduism? I Some of my best friends are Hindus.

11:15 ↗

But, that's a a non-theistic religion. So, >> He doesn't have any Hinduist Hindu friends. >> So, that was pretty easy one to to reject off the bat because it contradicts uh um uh plenty of uh logic and conclusions I've already come to about >> To sit here and say point at another religion and say it's illogical and it contradicts one another when your

11:42 ↗

religion is illogical and it contradicts itself is the cognitive dissonance is off the charts. >> uh the nature of being and who created everything. Uh okay, well, I think we've just handily gotten rid of all the other religions, right? Now, you might say, "Well, there's a lot of different sects of Christianity. >> That's it. We're done. All right. It's all right. God's God's real. Truth you know, the Bible's true.

12:08 ↗

All right. He convinced me. >> I mean, that's true. I just think that the historical claims and the theological claims of of the church uh go back to antiquity. They're well attested to over 2,000 years and so that's how I landed on that one. Your mileage may vary. Maybe you come to a different one, but at the very least we we've landed roughly in the neigh- >> Okay, so basically he's advocating here for a form of evidentialism, I would guess. Natural theology.

12:35 ↗

Basically trying to use um I mean, he basically asserts religious beliefs can and should be evaluated based on rational evidence, which is absolutely insane to say as any kind of religious believer because it's so easy then. What a Why would you take on that burden of proof? Like I I don't understand it. Why would you take this burden of proof

13:01 ↗

on? >> neighborhood of one another here. We don't just have to throw up our hands and say, "Well, you know, Johnny says this and Jack says that, so who the hell knows? Everyone can believe whatever they want. Let's not try to arrive at any >> Why did you become religious? >> Uh I was persuaded of it. You know, I was an atheist for 10 years, but uh that view >> He wasn't an atheist. I guarantee you he was not an atheist for 10 years.

13:27 ↗

I have to dig more into that. I'm just saying that, but oh my god, I'd put so much money on it. I got to look this up. I got to look this up. Hold on. Like there's just no way Michael Knowles was an atheist for 10 years. I mean, I guess how would I really find that out, but there's got to be something out here. Hold on. Michael Knowles fell I mean, this again,

13:52 ↗

take it as it will, this is a quick Google search, but Michael Knowles fell away from the Catholic Church at age 13 and spent a decade as an atheist, like every other [ __ ] teenager. He concluded that logic of atheism could not hold up. What is the logic of atheism? Like it maybe he didn't say these words. But what is the logic of logic of

14:17 ↗

atheism is that I don't see enough evidence to believe in God. He ultimately reverted to his faith after realizing that the smartest people at Yale were Christian and encountering philosophical questions regarding the universe's precise laws, objective morality, which is no such thing. Maybe there is, but that's another argument for another time, and the necessity of a first cause. Oh, we're

14:44 ↗

going to get some goddamn Aquinas. That is full show. >> Who just is not tenable. What about it? Well, it doesn't explain anything. >> [laughter] >> Why do you need things explained? >> Because I'm a rational person >> But how does it not explain How does it not explain certain things? I feel like like just by chance is an explanation, right? >> How does the chance come about? How does anything come about? >> It just That's the nature of I feel like just chance.

15:10 ↗

>> one could discuss chance and probability and I don't know, stochastic systems or whatever. >> The thing is, and this is not believe it is the consensus, but the universe could be infinite. There was a a leading theory in cosmology right now called the the big crunch, which basically just talks about the universe

15:35 ↗

going from you know, a condensed state and expanding and then coming back in on itself and then expanding infinitely. Like just doing that over billions and billions of years infinitely. Like so if the universe is infinite, the chances of us being here is 100%. >> Ever. But that

16:00 ↗

you can only do that within the context of a created world, right? You can only do that within the context of I'm a human being with a brain. I think with faculties of reason on planet Earth within a universe. And so at a certain point you have to ask, well, how did all of that come about? And there are plenty of ways to do it. You can ask how anything is in motion. An object >> Oh, yeah. Here comes Aquinas. >> when some other object puts it puts it in motion. Well, what happens when you go all the way back down the line? You

16:26 ↗

need to have an unmoved mover. How how are >> [laughter] >> Oh, yes. I knew it. I knew it was going to be Aquinas all day. Basically, the unmoved mover thing is everything has a cause. Therefore, God. >> How do effects come about? >> So bad. >> I smack you across the face. I would never do such a thing cuz I'm a lover, not a fighter, but then you would have a little red mark on your face. That's an

16:51 ↗

effect and the cause was my slap. Well, why did I slap you? I don't know cuz I drank too much coffee this morning. Well, that was the cause and the effect was my irritability. Well, where did the coffee come from? You go all the way back down the line of causes. There has to be an uncaused cause, doesn't there? A perfect >> No. No, there doesn't have to be an uncaused cause. Things could have always just been. And then you come into the issue of your God, then what caused your God? And what

17:17 ↗

created that god? It's [ __ ] turtles all the way down. >> The fact that some things are better than other things, the fact that we would all agree even if you're like a nice happy skeptical person, we all agree that it's better to help a little old lady cross the street than it is to kick a newborn baby in the head. Right? I think we would all agree with that. Okay, well if some things are better than other things then there has to be a maximally great thing. Traditionally called the summum bonum. >> Oh my god, the summum bonum.

17:44 ↗

Oh my gosh. Young talks about the summum the summum bonum I believe it's called. He might be pronouncing it correctly. I don't know. The summum bonum I thought it was but whatever it's Latin. The greatest good. So, yeah. Most contemporary philosophers reject the premise that comparative evaluations need to have some kind of ontologically maximum great thing to exist.

18:14 ↗

I mean they're usually I would say they're viewed as human conceptual constructs or evolutionary adaptations essentially. Like there's no reason to once again assert without any evidence that there has to be some maximally great good thing in order for us I'm assuming he's would take this if this was a longer

18:40 ↗

conversation into objective morality. But it's just so dumb. >> Well, who is that maximally great thing? That would that would be god. There are many other arguments too. I mean that's just a handful off the top of my head but >> And they're all bad and they all fail. >> Those observations necessarily entail coming to the conclusion that atheism is just like Reddit tier 2006 bunk. What prompted that though? There's got to be an

19:06 ↗

>> [laughter] >> Again, I can't say this enough. For anybody listening who doesn't know anything about atheism, it is nothing except a lack of belief in a god. Again, some people might take a hard atheistic stance and say god does not exist, but most say I have not seen sufficient enough evidence to say or

19:33 ↗

believe that there is a god. >> Any event that happened made you think, that pushed you in that direction. >> I met smart people, I guess. I mean, this really started my freshman year of college. And I I diss my college sometimes >> Okay, so maybe this Google AI overview is right. >> just cuz it's kind of a super liberal and gone completely off the rails, but there are a lot of intelligent people at it. A lot of them are atheists, no

19:58 ↗

question about it. I noticed the very smartest people were religious, and they presented me with >> This is a made-up story. >> arguments, you know, we're just having double debates and things. Chat They were challenging my thinking, and I didn't have an answer for the arguments that they were making. And so if you have any kind of humility at all, then you you have to say, "Huh." You know, you never do it in the moment. You never say, "Yeah, you're totally right, man. I can see the debate." In

20:23 ↗

the moment you'll say, "You're totally wrong. You're a big jerk." Whatever. But then you go home, and if you have any humility whatsoever, you think about it. You say, "Huh." >> Yeah, I guess that guy That's the first thing he said that I agreed with. >> I was right. I guess I did lose that debate. And then once you do that for long enough, you you come to the uh the correct conclusions, hopefully. >> Was your wife on board with the decision to go on a certain way for a religion? >> She was freaked out by it. She was freaked out. Cuz look, we grew up in a

20:49 ↗

big agnostic liberal New York play. Everyone was functionally an atheist, anyway. Whatever their nominal you know, some people were nominally Jews, some people were nominally Catholics, but >> But I thought he was only an atheist till he was 23. Then again, if he's a Christian, he probably got married at 17 so he could have sex. >> Um basically everyone was a practical >> A lot of generalizations there. >> atheist a liberal really. I mean they

21:15 ↗

just they believed what you articulated at the beginning which is you do you, leave it alone, we can't really know anything, I don't know, whatever, you know. And and I don't mean to diss it. I don't mean to be dismissive in any way. That's that is the zeitgeist, man. That is the culture we're living in, but uh as a result of that >> Being an atheist is a minority. >> When I came around I said, "Hey, you're going to this is my freak out, but uh

21:41 ↗

I think God exists." It's so fun It's so funny. This is the thing that virtually everyone believed for all of human history, but now if you say it's kind of like >> [snorts] >> it's a little radical. >> What is the act? What is the act of acting like being a Christian is some taboo [ __ ] thing in this country? It doesn't even make any sense. The vast majority of conservatives are

22:07 ↗

Christian. The vast majority of Republicans are Christian. The vast majority of this country, even people who don't necessarily believe will say they're Christian and still go to [ __ ] church. Like there is no They act like they're getting hung and strung out and they're victims. >> radical. And I said, "Look, I'm going to go to mass

22:33 ↗

this weekend. I'm going to go to church. You don't have to come. But I don't I'm just going to go cuz I think I should." She said, "Okay." And she kind of, you know, she went with me just to kind of She was freaked out, man. She became less freaked out over time, obviously. You know, we were married in the church and everything, but but uh it can be very jarring. I mean, it's very This is why I keep coming back to liberalism because I don't I don't mean

22:59 ↗

it in in the own the libs way. I mean it in the like recognize the error that you're moving in way. We live in in a liberal age where all the premises of liberalism are just what we believe. We don't even think about it. And it's not our fault. We don't you know you don't wake up every day and write a five-page report on whether you're going to have waffles or pancakes for breakfast. You just do things, you know, we we we are animals of prejudice and we just kind of go about our habits, right?

23:25 ↗

But when you start to pull at that thread and this is why to bring us all the way back full circle. This is why the trans issue keeps coming up. Because the trans issue >> [laughter] >> Trans issue keeps coming up cuz you idiots are obsessed with weeners and vaginas getting cut off. >> is just it's so absurd. Everybody knows a man in a dress is not really a woman. But

23:50 ↗

>> This is such a [ __ ] straw man already. It's such a [ __ ] straw man. >> the logical conclusion of liberalism. It's also the logical conclusion of radical self-sovereignty. It's also the radical of I'm going to make my own reality. I'm going to have my own truth. And >> That's [ __ ] rich coming from a Christian. I'm going to have my own truth. >> So once you pull at that thread, you can't you can't stop pulling. The whole thing starts to unravel. So you say,

24:16 ↗

"Okay, yeah, we shouldn't trans the kids. We shouldn't really trans anybody." >> We shouldn't trans the kids. What a [ __ ] idiot this guy is. >> [laughter] >> Oh my gosh. I I fully agree with bodily autonomy. Heavily I fully agree with liberal individualism. Like every person as long

24:41 ↗

as they're not harming anyone else should be able to do whatever the [ __ ] they want. Whether that's drugs, whether that's a sex change, or whatever. But to categorize just even liberal individualism as making my own reality contradicts the whole entire medical consensus. Like gender dysphoria is a documented psychological reality. Requires it has it's it's evidence-based.

25:08 ↗

Nobody's going to school getting their wieners chopped off. And the only reason we keep talking about it and I when I say we, I guess I mean liberals and people on the left keep talking about this is cuz you guys are obsessed with it. And that's just how you idiots get people on your side cuz you make up lies and people are getting their wieners chopped off in school and coming home a different sex and dumbasses believe it

25:34 ↗

because that's about what people do. They watch [ __ ] Netflix and sports and then just listen to whoever they agree with and just don't ever question it. Like Jesus [ __ ] Christ, people. Like gender and sex are two different things. It's not a It's not a hard concept to put your [ __ ] head around. I get that it's weird and it creeps you out because you think you might like a

26:01 ↗

dude in a dress, but get the [ __ ] over it. Unfucking real that this is still a topic that people are arguing over. >> Actually, men and women are different, which means that marriage is what it used >> Nobody says men and women aren't different. >> to mean not what people say it means now, which means that feminism is kind of bunk, too, which means that liberalism is kind of bunk, which means we're not actually not radical individuals. We're not just We don't

26:27 ↗

make ourselves. We don't Oh my goodness gracious. The last 500 years has been a total series of error. What if >> So, once again, sex and gender are different. One is a sociological concept. The other is a biological concept. They're two totally different things and this is what is so annoying to me

26:52 ↗

about people who are just won't shut up about trans [ __ ] Like let [ __ ] people do them. And gender dysphoria is a real [ __ ] thing that people are born with. There are often times people are there children born where they have both [ __ ] parts and a parent has to choose. Like this is [ __ ] ridiculous that this is even a up for debate.

27:18 ↗

But this is what happens when you live in a Jordan Peterson post-modern [ __ ] conservative run world. Is science doesn't mean science, facts don't mean facts, words don't mean words, and then anytime you show a peer-reviewed study, science is corrupted. The whole [ __ ] goddamn world of science is corrupted for climate change, [ __ ] vaccines, for uh transgender

27:43 ↗

issues. Like this is [ __ ] ridiculous and you have a cop out the whole time. And this is why it's so funny when people on the right were accusing people on the left of being post-modernist cuz that's all people on the right are now. >> [music]