REACTION / RELIGION

The Jordan Peterson CULT: The Debate That Broke The Camels Back

The first Room 9 livestream, with some early audio issues.

THE WORDS BEHIND THE VIDEO

TRANSCRIPT.

YouTube-generated captions, grouped into readable passages. These have not been human-corrected and may contain errors, especially names, punctuation, and overlapping speech. Timestamp links open the matching moment on YouTube.

267 timestamped passages

0:05 ↗

[music] [music] [music] [music]

1:02 ↗

[music]

1:40 ↗

[music] [music] Heat. Heat.

2:24 ↗

[music] Heat. Heat. [music] [music] >> [music]

3:02 ↗

[music] [music] [music]

3:28 ↗

>> Heat. Heat. [music]

4:02 ↗

Heat. Hey, heat. Hey, heat. >> [music] [music] >> Good night.

4:35 ↗

>> [music] >> Heat. Heat.

5:10 ↗

>> [music] [music] [music]

5:37 ↗

[music] [music]

6:08 ↗

>> Heat up

6:35 ↗

here. Hey, hey, hey.

7:02 ↗

Come >> [music]

7:27 ↗

>> here. [music] >> [music]

7:57 ↗

[music] [music]

8:29 ↗

>> You want to [music] heat?

9:00 ↗

and we are going to get this thing moving. [clears throat] Got people lining up in the chat like always. I'm just joking. There's nobody there. Thank the Lord because I don't know what the hell I'm doing at the moment. But let me check some volume. Um, let me get something else up on YouTube first because I got this queued up and ready to go. But this is the continuation

9:27 ↗

of the series of how I deconstructed from Jordan Peterson. It's funny to say it like that, but man, there's a there's a lot of other crazies uh that follow this dude because they think he sounds smart until you actually read what he's talking about.

9:52 ↗

Says a lot of true things, don't get me wrong, but he says a lot of [ __ ] that there's not much evidence to say, and he says it very matterof factly, that's for sure. And don't get me going on I'm going to do a full episode on it probably pretty soon. Although a lot of people have done done it better than way better than I have. But just at least a quick summary of Peterson's

10:19 ↗

terrible misrepresentations of NZA. It's mad. That was one of the biggest things for me. Uh the video I'm going to show today was the beginning was like the the starting catalyst. It did start with I remember the what is truth debate Peterson did with Sam Harris a long time ago and it was just it was maddening to listen to. So, I don't know if I'll

10:45 ↗

encourage anybody to go listen to it, but I did listen to it a lot because I wanted to because I like both Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson. And so, I wanted to find out, all right, you know, who's [ __ ] right here? Like, or at least who has more basis to say that they're right. But other than those, this video today was one of the biggest ones that really

11:10 ↗

started to change my way of thinking. >> [clears throat] >> It was also after I started realizing that Peterson did not really represent Nichol on the things that he said. He at least misrepresent him. But I'm going to check some audio real quick here. >> Name's bar, by the way. Red Bar. >> Let me see. >> All my permits are current. >> Thought that was cute. We're here

11:36 ↗

because of how Joe's been treating his good friend Ari Schaffer. Parish fear. Many times we've caught him in the wild. He loves Redbar. Redbar is funny. Redbar has the right >> to exist. I don't know. I think Joe >> starting to politically start hating Ari based on his uh the Jewish thing is really getting in the way. You could see on this protect our parks you had Mark Norman, >> Shane Gillis, Ari Shafir.

12:02 ↗

>> You could see Shane was picking on Ari a lot about the Israel Palestine thing. And it sounds like Shane is fully on the side of Palestine. He sounded like he was really Well, what what are they doing this for, Ari? >> Yeah, I don't think he was kidding. >> Seems like there's some bad blood there. Okay, >> I like you like stand up here. >> Travel podcast. You've been tripping about now here, this out there, this out

12:29 ↗

there. It's all under the umbrella of these guys doing [ __ ] >> I think travel podcast. >> What do that little tuft isn't coming? >> I know. He's getting into dark territory. >> What is going to happen? I mean, we're going to have a Castanza very This is >> unless >> Okay, it's pretty good monitoring. It looks like everything is going out to YouTube. Good. I guess I'll find out when I rewatch this and we'll have to just

12:55 ↗

start over. But all right, let's get into it. So this was the big debate for me that absolutely made me kind of just start questioning a lot of my own beliefs essentially that was very much well in this whole like

13:20 ↗

deconstructed from Christianity and then got into that whole kind of spiritual but not religious and then moved into the you know eastern philosophical realm, you know, very much well Alan Watts and Buddhism and Zen Buddhism and just which I still love reading to this day. It's very enjoyable. Um, Zen is hysterical like when certain things click in your mind.

13:47 ↗

Zen, it's just like you laugh it. So, I've always enjoyed Eastern philosophy. Um, but anyway, so I was kind of in that phase. [cough and clears throat] Oh my gosh, it's cold. And then I moved more into the young and then all that, you know, spirit science and, you know, all this other [ __ ] Um, you know, quantum mechanics that, you know,

14:12 ↗

consciousness affects matter and then, you know, you start uh realizing you got to start questioning things more deeply. How do we know we know? Logic was probably one of the biggest things. Not that I know [ __ ] about propositional logic, but I know enough and it started making me really tear down my belief systems one by one, which

14:38 ↗

can be very troublesome. Um, like young Peterson gets very very lost into these symbols. And I'm not saying there's nothing to any of it because there's a lot to it, but people get lost and obsessed with them. so much that everything turns into a symbol or a sign or a deeper meaning or a deeper value. And then unlike Jung,

15:04 ↗

Peterson takes it a step further and he sprinkles this freaking religious language onto scientific language to make it sound like he's right or he has evidence to say what he's saying. And it's he's constantly doing a M Bailey fallacy and he just says something outrageous and then he retreats to the smaller claim like, "No, I didn't say that. I meant this." And it's it's ridiculous to be

15:29 ↗

quite honest. Um yeah. So I guess let's just get this [ __ ] going. So this is a debate hosted by Pang Burn. I want to start off the bat, the first thing I realized when I first watched this years ago, Peterson just does not, unlike when he was on the stage with Sam Harris, like just does not feel comfortable. He

15:57 ↗

feels tense. He feels on edge a little bit. I don't know if anybody else picks up on that. Leave, let me know if you think you picked up on that, too. But [snorts] I just I feel like that was a big thing for me with this is like Peterson seemed unsure of himself at times and so much so he just makes some ridiculous claims. Some very ridiculous claims. But without further ado, let's kick it off.

16:22 ↗

>> Quick and easy and simple like God. Uh in particular, I I don't believe there is one and I have no idea what your thoughts are on it. You mean the pain? I don't know if I should be commenting him right now, but >> I mean just about the subject in general, but I'm happy to hear your thoughts on about what I don't think as well. Maybe.

16:55 ↗

>> Well, it's a complicated problem. >> That was weird. >> And I don't think that we take it with due seriousness. I specifically don't think that the celebrity atheist types, who I actually have a fair bit of respect for, by the way, take it with due seriousness. So, I don't think that they take it with due seriousness from a biological perspective or a phenomenological perspective or a literary perspective or

17:23 ↗

a metaphoric perspective. That'll do for starters. Um, I become convinced that the fundamental presuppositions of our very functional cultures or western cultures say are nested immovably in a metaphorical substrate and that when you enter that metaphorical substrate, you're in the domain of religious

17:49 ↗

phenomenology. And I think that not only can you derive that conclusion as a consequence of deep philosophical thought and literary analysis, but it but that if you know enough about brain function, you'll also come to the same conclusion. I think you come to the same conclusion as well. If you look at the evolution of religious cognition from the perspective of an evolutionary biologist and not

18:16 ↗

from the position of a evolutionary biologist whose head is addled by the belief that most of human morality was established in the 500 years since the enlightenment. So that's a start I guess.

19:59 ↗

except and uh so you have to bear with me. >> Yeah, >> cuz I'm from Texas. >> That's okay. I'm from Alberta. You know, it's bigger than Texas. Just as bad. >> Yeah. [applause] So the cur the curious thing for me is um all of that applies seemingly if I'm understanding it to uh religious thought

20:26 ↗

uh religious tradition the value of religious identity to individuals and I don't see that any of it relates to whether or not there is a god or whether or not there's sufficient reason to believe

23:39 ↗

They've been [ __ ] on mute this whole time. Jesus. Get it together, bro. Okay, I'll start back over there for a second. Basically in a nutshell what I was just saying is that Peterson was basically [clears throat] when he argues this the whole Christian morality thing um he claims exactly I'm going to read it right now because I wrote it down when I was re-watching

24:05 ↗

this in regards to Christian fundamentalism fundamentalists Peterson agrees they suffer from the illusion that the Bible has the same epistemological and ontological status as scientific theory. However, he sympathizes with them because they are trying to protect the narrative corpus in which the western moral ethos is nested against rationalist atheists who would blow that foundation apart.

24:32 ↗

I could do a whole freaking episode on this because secular humanists have something to replace it with now as opposed to what Nze was writing. But this was basically taken from Nichze's critique of secular moralists and he believe it was Twilight of idols and the gay science. Um he talks about um basically argued that when one gives up Christian faith,

24:59 ↗

one pulls the right to Christian morality out from under one's feet essentially. Um, and it's just I love that again this is almost like a misrepresentation because he should if I was saying what Peterson was saying right there I would also say even though Nietze believed that we could replace it and there was a certain group of people who would be

25:24 ↗

able to do this. One of my biggest critiques and one of the biggest things that I noticed off the bat when I started reading Icha was how much Peterson misrepresented his idea of the death of God. Because it's ironically Peterson says, "Oh, he wasn't saying it triumphantly." But he kind of was saying it

25:49 ↗

triumphantly. The madman man, the mad man was appalled because he realized nobody around him in the story knew the consequences of it, but he also talked about how this would be one of the greatest things for what he calls freethinkers. So, it's just another cop out of that. And then the concept of this this metaphorical substrate, this religious phenomenality is definitely young in

26:17 ↗

um I believe it came from his book, the archetypes and the collective unconscious. And in there he kind of posits uh myths and religious symbols are inherited evolutionarily psychic structures rather than failed protoscientific theories. So you can start seeing like if you start reading Young and Nichze, you just

26:42 ↗

know Peterson basically and then Peterson takes that and misrepresents both of them several several times. But we'll get on with uh Matt's point here. >> There's a God, which is my sticking point. I I'm fully fine with the idea. Oh yeah. Yeah. We'll we'll try and get through this without like rockus applause, but you know, hey, at least I got one.

27:08 ↗

>> But and essentially, sorry, real quick. Essentially too, Matt's trying to say here that we are not talking about the same type of Christians. Anyway, at least when people believe the Bible is inherent, they vote on it. They actively will shame and think that homosexuals are

27:34 ↗

sinners. That the encourages misogyny. I mean, it encourages all this crazy freaking vile [ __ ] in the laws of Moses. But if you're just following things like, oh yeah, this is all metaphors and cool stories that we can learn lessons from. I mean, I go for it. That's cool. Go for it. >> One. [laughter] >> Yeah. You don't never complain about

27:59 ↗

rockus applause.

28:53 ↗

be made but it's a lot more difficult than people generally think and I also think that there's no doubt that there are different levels of sophistication of religious belief you know what I see happening in this sort of discussion say frequently um you know and again like I said I have a fair bit of respect ect for the atheist types because they spend a lot of time thinking and that's generally a good thing. No, I see most of the of their thinking, however,

29:18 ↗

directed at the fundamentalist types, the fundamentalist Christian types, mostly of the American persuasion who suffer from the >> So, I just want to bust in here and say if you're going by the scholarly consensus on things, like generally speaking, the vast majority of scholars and scientists and philosophers

29:43 ↗

don't hold to this pragmatic William James type of truth. It's a super minority. I mean, compared to the analytic philosophical correspondence theories of truth, like they just they don't hold up together because yes, you can sometimes argue that believing um a tiger was in the bush when it was just

30:08 ↗

the wind is better than believing it's the wind when there's a tiger in the bush. Sure. And it's good to have a reflex to that, but it still doesn't mean it was true. If you jumped back because the wind rustled some bushes and you thought it was a tiger, it doesn't mean it's true because it saved your could have saved your life or, you know, it just it's ridiculous to even think that. I don't even understand why that's a thought. the [snorts]

30:37 ↗

somewhat understandable illusion that the biblical corpus [clears throat] has the same epistemological and onlogical status as a scientific theory when it clearly doesn't. Right? I mean, if you're >> okay, now we're closer to the same page. >> Okay? If you're a religious thinker, let's say, if you're a serious student of religious thought and a serious philosopher, the one thing, one of the things you can't claim is that whatever story the Bible

31:04 ↗

is telling is a scientific theory. And that's just self-evident. First of all, like when was the first scientist? Deart, Bacon, Newton. Maybe you could chase it back to the Greeks, but no farther than that. And so the idea that whatever the people who conjured up the Old Testament creation account were doing was something akin to scientific theorizing is a mistake that would only be made by people who don't know how to distinguish between different kinds of

31:31 ↗

truth. And so the fundamentalists like so the different kind of truths I kind of touched on in my little audio test video yesterday or two days ago. There's propositional knowledge, perspectival knowledge. Those are both kind of set in cognitive neuroscience. John Reviki adds two more which is participatory and procedural.

32:02 ↗

The problem is with all these and I'm I'm going to I'm doing a deep dive into it now because I'm trying to figure it out exactly. All of those things either start or end with or both with propositional knowledge. Like the whole idea of this this

32:27 ↗

metaphorical knowledge and this is it's just absolutely insane. I also I feel for the fundamentalists, you know, because what they're trying to do to give them credit is to maintain a corpus of stories in which an ethos is based. That would be the western ethos for in in in this case of Christianity because they believe that the ethos is of extreme value. And I also believe that the ethos

32:54 ↗

is of of extreme value and that it is nested in those stories. And so they don't like to be confronted by the rationalist atheist evolutionary types because it blows the foundation of their ethos apart and they feel that it's worth preserving. And I think well yeah it is worth preserving. Now >> why is it worth preserving? Why?

33:20 ↗

as I'm going to get to here shortly is there's a completely secular objective moral system you can go on which is great and secondly Christian morality is equally subjective as secular morality putting the argument of a more this moral realist argue secular moral

33:45 ↗

realist argument I have um it's just subjective If you think there is a God, if you believe the Bible's inherent, you believe there's a God with a mind outside of space and time presumably, which is insane to say, or living in the sky somewhere, and you just take your morals from him, which is his God's subjective morals.

34:12 ↗

Subjective just means mind dependent. So if God has a mind, and if God doesn't have a mind, then what's the point? and now you're just using stupid language that muddies the waters. >> Now, that doesn't mean that there aren't philosophical problems associated with the manner in which they construct their arguments, but well, >> they're still worthy, but it doesn't

34:38 ↗

address the issue. There's a deep issue here that that that we're not contending with. You know, here's an example. This is maybe >> what's the deep issue? And he's going to go he's going to talk about DostI doski. He's going to talk about Iliad. He's going to talk about Yong. He's going to bring up [ __ ] uh Nietze. He's It's just like

35:04 ↗

I'm wrong about this, but I don't think so. Um, I just finished. Well, I I thought about it a lot, you know, and I do try to think about where I'm wrong because I would like to figure out where I'm wrong because then I wouldn't have to be wrong anymore, right? And being wrong is actually not a good thing. You fall into a pit if you're wrong. >> And this is what I point out in the lecture on skepticism since you didn't get to see the show is that being wrong feels exactly like being right. You don't, you know, nobody runs around

35:31 ↗

going, "Oh, I'm wrong, but I'm going to keep believing this." We all assume >> I love that line. And Matt uses that line quite often. Um, and I love it because it's true. It It makes me It makes me very humbled when I try to say things and, you know, talk with people because if you you're always going to think

35:56 ↗

you're right or else you wouldn't believe something. And this goes back to you don't choose your beliefs, right? No, you don't choose your beliefs. You go out into the world. There's things, there's experiences, you find better ways to find evidence and decide what's true and what's not true, but you don't choose any of them.

36:24 ↗

And what Peterson is saying here essentially is just that the heavy hitters, you know, in the religious phenomen phenomenology world like Dosi, Toltoy, Eliad, Yung, like and he's going to probably defend Young because people really did shrug Young

36:50 ↗

off as a mystic towards the end. But like Peterson, Young became so obsessed with symbols and this collective unconscious idea that we still don't really have any evidence for it just becomes an unhealthy manner. But let's >> assume that we are correct about a great many things. And it is it's not so much

37:15 ↗

that being wrong is the thing we're afraid of. It's I think that being exposed as wrong is the thing we're afraid >> well we're we're also sometimes afraid of being wrong because if you're wrong at a deep level it can really hurt you. >> Oh I agree >> can really take you apart and so people don't like to >> so that's a youngian idea. I'm never going to get through this video if I keep pausing it. That's a young idea. It's come on I'm having a brain fart.

37:42 ↗

the uh yian disintegration uh psychic dissolution which is basically the collapse of the persona the ego and it goes into chaos you all experience it if you've ever taken psychedelics it can be very and nobody wants to believe like the mo people I have the most respect for in the effing world

38:08 ↗

are the atheists that I come across us on YouTube who were pastors for 40, 50 years. Like I cannot imagine running a church for 35, 40 years. You went to school for all this 354 years and then having this then realizing that it's all [ __ ]

38:37 ↗

so much respect for those people who can get out of it. Because I totally understand why there's probably so many pastors in the world that don't believe in God anymore, but are still running their church, preaching every Sunday, saying that the word of God is perfect and inherent. And it's got to be ripping them apart inside. I just it's not easy to go back

39:03 ↗

in your beliefs. For me, like deconstructing from Christianity was so difficult because I had escape. I had something to give me comfort that I was going to see my dead brother and sister again one day. Like they died when I was 15 and on, you know, in Thanksgiving of 99. And I wanted to hold on to that like all right, I'm going to see him one day. But

39:29 ↗

it started raising all these questions in my mind when people would tell me, "Oh, they're in a better place. you'll see him again one day. And it's like, am I? How do you know that? First off, it's in the Bible. Well, that doesn't count as evidence cuz that's the claim. So, how do you know that? And I want to know, do they age? Like, are my brother and sister going to be the same age? So, if I die when I'm 70, is my brother

39:54 ↗

still going to be 18 when I see him? Like, how how does all that work? [clears throat] And that's what started my deconstruction. Um, I ignored it for a long time and didn't really start till my mid20s, but anyway, that's another video >> to be taken apart. Like if you're wrong about your wife, for example, that tends to be a very painful thing and and that's that's something that's worth pursuing to to try to >> frying pan [laughter]

40:22 ↗

>> that should make you popular. Um, okay. So, so one of the issues that that I have and and you can respond to this is that the the let's say the celebrity atheist types because I actually like that phrase. Um they don't seem to me to be contending with the real issues. They seem to be >> such a dumb phrase. >> Doski, he's a real issue. Toltoy, he's a real issue. Carl Jung, 20 books and

40:47 ↗

maybe 15 seminars, he's a real issue. Eliada like there are some serious heavy hitters in the religious phenomenology domain and my sense so far I just finished reading all of Harris's books for example he doesn't contend with them at all and it's like for me that's like being an evolutionary biologist and not being aware of Darwin it's actually a big problem >> Harris didn't have to contend with them

41:13 ↗

because Harris wrote his own book on secular objectives and secular morality I don't think I have it up here. It's downstairs in the room in the library. Yeah. No, I don't have it up here. The moral landscape. That's what it's called. Yeah. And he did a fairly good job of it. He did say he talked about like presupposing rules for it such as

41:40 ↗

well-being, but we do that all the time. And that's not even my my argument for objective. I think there's a better one by Gorth and I totally stole it from this other guy. But anyway, like why does he have to like does he have to mention them personally? What's what does this mean? >> It's not something you can handwave away. Jung [clears throat] was a mystic. It's like sorry he was about as smart as

42:08 ↗

Friedrich Nichze. >> I think this gets to basically the same point I was talking about before. The thing that you're objecting to, it seems, is that uh many of us don't want to to address the aspects of religion that you find value in because we're only focused on perhaps as I'm talking in the show from a scientific skepticism perspective of do we are there are there valid and sound arguments that would lead one to

42:34 ↗

conclude that a god exists? My answer to this so far seems to be no. And the the apologists, the theologians, uh they keep presenting the arguments, the teological arguments, moral arguments, and all these things. They have nothing to do with the phenomenology of religion. They have >> correct. Bingo. It's such a perfect [ __ ] thing to say right there. Such a beautiful way to put it because

43:00 ↗

yes, it has nothing to do with phenomenology. It's all ontology. the teological argument argument from design. You have Aquinus's his five ways, the cosmological arguments. You got the moral argument like but none of them address the phenomenology of religion.

43:25 ↗

None of them nothing to do with how this impacts people's lives. This is a question of is it in fact the case? >> Is it in fact the case that a god exists? Nothing on how it affects affects people phenomen phenomenologically. One of my biggest things I notice all

43:50 ↗

the time just even talking with your everyday Joe online is the fact that um they do not understand the difference between ontology and phenomenology and they continuously hop back and forth between the two as they're talking. So it's like if your experience your phenomenology like you experienced this thing with God

44:18 ↗

you were struggling. You know your family member just died. You went to church and all of a sudden you had these this awe, this emotion, this feeling. you saw your daughter who just passed away appear in front of you and came up and you know gave you a hug and it just it was this great and it just proved God to you but that's does not address the ontology of something

44:44 ↗

the phenomenology of something is your experience and nobody can deny that to you but the ontology of something is totally different like your personal experience is ever going to convince me that a god exists? >> Is it consistent with reality that there is a god and is it consistent with reality that there is good reason

45:15 ↗

I would never construed a scientific issue because science can't confirm the supernatural. I mean we are blocked until somebody demonstrates a mechanism by which we can explore >> uh and confirm the existence of the supernatural. >> The only people who are construing it with a scientific issue are the people who are freaking arguing that the literal god of the Bible exists.

45:40 ↗

Atheists just lack a belief. That's it. Simple. I don't see enough evidence to say such and such god exists. Like, and this is this whole like basically these two are talking past one another the whole time. And I think Matt does a great job of trying to get Jordan to realize this throughout. Like there's a big difference

46:06 ↗

between how religion affects your life and whether it is true or not. And that's the whole argument once again of, you know, Peterson saying it's not easy to decipher what's true, the difference between what's true and what's real. He's essentially saying religious religion helps people. And that's a whole another argument, but it's oh, it's so frustrating. >> And then confirm that it actually can impact the natural world, we're stuck,

46:32 ↗

which is why science relies on methodological naturalism. >> You seem to be able to do it with psychedelic drugs. You seem to be able to do what was >> just before we get into this. This is the the most ridiculous part. >> Psychedelic drugs. >> Well, everybody that takes them in and under under reliable settings generally comes back and and claims the presence of a mystical experience and that seems to be duplicatable and replicable across

46:59 ↗

>> again phenomenology. You take a drug, you have this mystical experience, this beautiful experience says nothing about whether or not that experience you had was true. I have taken very high amount doses of psilocybin mushrooms. Couple times, seven and a half grams to

47:25 ↗

the point where I couldn't figure out what I, you meant. But never once did I come out of that thinking any of that was like re real in the sense of like you know when I see something or have this experience I can pull great lessons out that learn and change my mind and help me become a better human being but it doesn't mean

47:53 ↗

those were actually real experiences >> cultures in labs with multiple different substances, the chemical constituents of which are known very well. It's like it's part of this religious phenomenology. And to me, we can at least infer that and we have no no idea whatsoever how much of an

48:20 ↗

effect the use of those substances has had on the metaphysical substrate of our culture. Like so what constitutes scientific word by no means clear here's an example of this for example so >> well before the example >> as someone who's been high as a kite >> I I fully agree that people take drugs and report experiences that they describe as mystical or supernatural

48:47 ↗

just like people record report other experiences as if they were religious or ghosts or whatever. We have no way of confirming that this something mystical or supernatural actually can happened. What this is, this is about the language >> stops people from smoking. >> Well, it stops people's from smoking. Oh my gosh. Oh my gosh. So, he's pretty sure in here he Jordan just brought up the John Hopkins and yes,

49:16 ↗

hands down. Absolutely. Mushrooms and therapy, MDMA and therapy can help people quit smoking drug. It can help people get over PTSD. It can help people do so many things. I think I have the study here.

49:41 ↗

One second. I'm trying to find it. Sorry. um a study by Ron Griffith and Matthew Johnson 2011 2014 2016. So that's what he's citing the data from. [snorts] Um it's combined psilocybin and uh CBT cognitive behav cognitive behavioral therapy and it about 67% were absident from

50:08 ↗

smoking cigarettes for 12 months and mystical experience questionnaire scores significantly correlated with craving reduction. Griffith's off also documented an increase in the big five trait openness of roughly one standard deviation. And Griffith confirmed large reductions in cancer related existential distress. Beautiful. Yep. I'm going to have to

50:35 ↗

actually get these studies. Don't argue with it. Totally good. Totally good with it. The scientific consensus along with Dillah Hunty what he just says here his interpretation of it of the mechanism they do not contribute it to phenomenology or they contribute to phenomenology they do not whatsoever

51:01 ↗

say that it confirms a religious onlogical supernatural realm. There's just no way do they say that whatsoever. And they certainly don't say it's the only way to quit smoking or to get off addiction. Like I killed my addiction with absolutely no psychedelic drugs whatsoever.

51:27 ↗

It's just bizarre statement. It's a M Bailey fallacy right there. >> You can stop smoking without any sort of supernatural intervention. No, not really. >> You can't stop smoking without super >> There aren't really any any reliable chemical means for inducing smoking sessation. You can use a drug called bup pryan. I think that's the one. >> Whatever wellran is. >> Um, >> is that supernatural? >> No, you don't need a supernatural

51:53 ↗

effect, but it doesn't work very well. But if you give people magic mushrooms, psilocybin, and they have a mystical experience, they have about an 85% chance of smoking sessation with one treatment. Yeah. But that's kind of like evidence, you know. >> It's kind of like evidence. >> It's evidence that you can take >> Yes. It's evidence that you can take mushrooms, have a mystical experience, and quit smoking. It's not evidence that

52:18 ↗

God exists. But as we all know, Jordan Pet doesn't Jordan Peterson doesn't believe in God. He believes God is the top of our hierarchy of values. that what we put our attention to most which instead of attention he would say worship most >> mushrooms and increase your chance of

52:44 ↗

quitting smoking but >> no it's not it's it's indication that if you take mushrooms and you have a mystical experience you'll you'll stop smoking because it doesn't work if you >> if you take mushrooms and you have an experience that you describe as mystical um then you'll increase your chance of smoking but that doesn't tell me whether or not there was something uh to this notion that they had an experience that was supernatural in any sense. >> Well, it's not definitive evidence,

53:09 ↗

>> but it's not evidence at all. >> Oh, sure it is. Oh, sure it is. >> No, it >> How is it? Wait a second. Wait a second. >> That's wrong. >> Okay, >> it is evidence. >> So, because look, he's right. You want to You want to think through this skeptically? >> Okay, you have a pharmacological substance. It's psilocybin. You give it to people who are

53:36 ↗

for trying to commit to quit smoking. The psilocybin doesn't directly have an impact on the smoking behavior. It has to elicit what's described subjectively as a mystical experience. And you can get physiological indicators of that mystical experience. And you might say, well, that's not enough to prove that it's a mystical experience. But

54:01 ↗

you know, you're conscious and I accept that. It's like you accept all sorts of things without being able

54:27 ↗

to demonstrate their rel their validity on every possible objective. um with every possible objective criteria. So don't get in too much of a hurry. It's a serious issue. If you give people psilocybin, for example, and they have a mystical experience, not only are they much more likely to quit smoking, which is really something, but they're also much less likely to suffer from death anxiety if they have cancer. Like that's quite the thing. And not only that, if

54:54 ↗

you test them a year later and they've had a mystical experience, which the majority of them regard as the most significant one or two, three, one, two, or three experiences of their life, including such things as getting married, their personalities are permanently altered in the direction of more openness to experience and more creativity by a standard deviation. Like that's walloping effects. So we can't get too much in a hurry about dispensing with all that. I so

55:21 ↗

skepticism as I repeatedly point out in the show is not about cynicism. It's not about debunking. And I'm not saying that there is no supernatural and that there is no mystical experience. What I'm saying is

56:21 ↗

The thing that people subjectively describe as I had an incredibly impactful mistful experience, whether it comes from taking a far [ __ ] a I had myself muted again. Jesus Christ. Get it together, bro. Basically, what I said real quickly is I'm going to have to edit this [ __ ] out. is that Matt's basically saying methodological naturalism obviously hence the name cannot study

56:50 ↗

anything that's supernatural like and until we have a way to test like I don't know nobody's saying for a matter of fact hey supernatural stuff does not exist ghosts don't exist God does not exist spirits don't exist But we have no way of testing that. And until we do, you can't say it's true. You just can't.

57:22 ↗

And this is the biggest confusion that so many people get. And even like my friends of mine who think all of a sudden I don't want to talk about these things because I don't believe any of it's true. It's cuz I just have to always remind them like I don't have enough evidence to say it's true. I'm fine with naval gazing. I'm fine with having these conversations. They're fun. I enjoy them. But to sit there and just straight up

57:49 ↗

say that atheists are denying strictly all of that like in a hard stance. It's just it's ridiculous. It's bad faith. And if anybody has had any moment in this, you know, this I guess I don't know realm or culture like they should know this >> whether it comes from attending a

58:15 ↗

revival church service or hearing a particular preacher, whether it comes from uh having a particularly impressive sexual experience, all of those things that is the subjective description of that which may be because of limitations in language that they don't have any other this is the language that infuses culture so that we have to use that to describe it but that doesn't in any way serve to confirm that there is any sort

58:40 ↗

of supernatural realm or any sort of supernatural actor >> well it depends on how you define supernatural like look I get your point okay and >> there's the natural world and then there's outside of the natural world and yes I'm not a prescriptivist so you can define words however you want, but let's just hear. >> I'm I'm not claiming that the the

59:06 ↗

phenomena of psilocybin intoxication is direct proof for the existence of God. I'm not saying that. >> That would be crazy if you were. And it sure seems like you're implying it. >> I am saying. >> Although that'd be awesome. [laughter] >> Well, people people do report personal experiences of that sort of thing. So it's not completely out of the realm of the experience, but it's also because of the the problem of the the border between the subjective and the

59:32 ↗

objective. It's it's difficult to probe deeply enough to to to come up with anything definitive, you know, and I understand that that's a problem. But the supernatural issue, that's that's a different issue. Like people are capable of entering different experiential realms where where things are qualitatively different to them. Their perceptions are different, the thoughts are different, their response to the world is different. They feel that

59:58 ↗

they've died an ego death and and and and and transcended their normal mode of perception. Like maybe that's not part of the supernatural. But then you're starting to define the supernatural pretty narrowly. >> No, it's not part of the supernatural. >> Like do do you require miracle like here and now? something that defies the laws of physics or what's your definition of

1:00:23 ↗

the supernatural? >> So there is the natural world. >> Yeah. >> And then there are people who make claims that something is not part of the natural world that it has some external supernatural origin. >> Um those are the claims that I don't see how we can make any sort of epistemologically sound confirmation of. I'm fine with accepting that people have these experiences. been, you know, I was for many many

1:00:50 ↗

years uh fundamentalist Southern Baptist and I remember standing in church and uh feeling what I would have described at the time as the Holy Ghost, you know, sweeping through me. Now, many years later, I look back at that and I say, why did I describe this particular experience this way? It is a it's a unique experience. It's of the same quality as >> something you might experience from a drug or I've experienced similar things

1:01:15 ↗

from music and drugs and sex, >> but they're not all exactly the same. And this is this is kind of the caveat that that the believers for any one of them would use is, "Oh, the thing you're talking about, you know, when you had awesome sex or you were on drugs, that's not the same as what I felt the Holy Spirit." I felt all of them. The reason I would have said at the time that I had been filled with the Holy Spirit is because everybody around me was saying that too. It's not like I have any sort of uh

1:01:41 ↗

any any way to demonstrate a causal connection between a Holy Spirit and my experience. It was I had an experience and I like everyone else around me attributed it to the Holy Spirit. >> What was the experience like? >> Elation, euphoria. Um >> I don't think I ever had visions. Uh but certainly it [clears throat] is it it was an overwhelming sensation. You know, you get the goosebumps or hair on your

1:02:07 ↗

And it was and I remember fairly distinctly the first time I had a very similar experience outside of church because uh it was from listening to secular music that my church would not have allowed. And then I began to look into things, you know, from far more of a psychological perspective of what type of impact specific music has on people. And you know, a friend of mine, we've had conversations about the cadence of

1:02:33 ↗

particular preachers >> because a Southern Baptist minister will have a different cadence than a Pentecostal preacher. And they'll have a different cadence than somebody else. And I I won't put on a performance to do them, but we have this intense curiosity as to is are the successful preachers with those cadence in conjunction with the music? Are they just tapping into some sort of psychological impact in our

1:02:58 ↗

brain in order to make us pliable in the same way that >> Oh, yeah. >> The elevator experiment where you have everybody face the back of the elevator. Somebody walks in and they face the doors and after a while a lot of them become uncomfortable and turn around and face >> Yeah. So, there's this great great great great book. I know I got it here. Come on. Come on. Come on. I'm using it actually for my monitor stand, but it's the um I got to get the

1:03:24 ↗

whole title right. Hold on a second. The extraordinary popular delusions and the madness of crowds and it's written by Charles Mccay. absolutely fabulous book that talks about how in groups basically it was like the beginning of crowd psychology, [clears throat] how people just go along with it. And Matt's talking about the

1:03:52 ↗

elevator experiment where you can just have everybody facing the back of the elevator, somebody gets on, they'll eventually do it as well. People just go go around with the crowd, >> face the back with everybody else for no reason. It's just compliance. Well, you don't want those backward facers to attack you. You know, >> it would be good, but if we're back to back, you know, I think Anyway, >> okay. So, let let me ask you a question about that, okay? Because I think this

1:04:17 ↗

gets to the heart of some of these issues. before people were experiencing a set of transcendent emotions that can be evoked by music and dance and and other forms of ritual and in a variety of other ways. But there's also a a profound proclivity on the part of people for one reason or another to attribute those to

1:04:43 ↗

some sort of supernatural agency. Yes. Now, okay. So, I want to separate that from another line of thinking. Okay. So, let's just leave that aside. So we could think of that as a a theory about the origin of of religious belief. The experience comes first. It comes along with a an implicit hypothesis about supernatural actors behind the scenes eliciting these experiences. Okay, that's in marked distinction to other theories of religious derivation like

1:05:09 ↗

Freud's theory for example that religion is a is a a defense against death anxiety or that or Marxist theory that religion is the opiate of the masses, right? It's a much more biological theory, the one we're putting forward. >> Sure. >> Okay. And it sounds, it seems to me to be a much more credible theory, even though religious movements can be harnessed for economic purposes and for purposes of manipulation and all of that, obviously. >> Yeah. I I would think that there's any number of explanations I've heard for

1:05:34 ↗

the origins of religion, and I find almost all of them plausible in different forms, except for the one that asserts that they come directly from a supernatural being. >> Well, okay. So that's that's the one we're going to that's the one we're going to pursue though because >> that was funnier than I thought it was. I was I was just being honest. >> Yeah. Well, honesty is often funnier than people think it is. Why don't I >> So um so okay so people can have these experiences and they can be evoked in a variety of ways and people often find

1:06:00 ↗

them very valuable at least in terms of their subjective report. >> I agree. and uh and the psilocybin experiments and also the large-scale analysis of psychedelic drug users by the way also indicate that the use of such substances is generally associated with an increment in health rather than a decrement which is quite interesting right it's not something you'd necessarily expect so here's a question

1:06:25 ↗

why in the world do the people who have these experiences have the proclivity to attribute them to supernatural sources like to a divine source Like what? What's going on There.

1:08:01 ↗

case. >> So best guess and and this is this is contrary. So the skepticism isn't about hey let's debunk this and come up with but if we were going to go through potential plausible explanations to me this is very similar to so I would think this is what I said because once again I got to stop muting myself. I don't know how I keep doing this. It's maddening. I mean, it's a good thing nobody's watching or probably will watch this yet, but holy cow, it drives me nuts.

1:08:29 ↗

But basically, Matt's going to talk about here like Peterson asked him the question. You heard that? You what's going on? So, culture convergence would be a great one. Pattern recognition, the hyper a active agency detection. I mean, humans evolve to see faces and patterns and assume a rustling bush in the predator/ agent rather than the wind when no physical

1:08:54 ↗

predators found. Humans infer an invisible spirit. Intuitive dualism regarding death. Seeing an animated person suddenly drop dead creates the the intuitive illusion that an animated soul has left the body, unlike a turned off television or radio. You know, in that sense, I'm just

1:09:22 ↗

I don't know. Like I try to put myself in the position of people who lived thousands and thousands of years ago before science knew anything about anything. And I try to imagine myself knowing that the crops I'm growing that I need rain from the sky to come down and water them in order for them to grow in order for me and my family and my

1:09:49 ↗

kids to eat. I would start praying to the sky. I would start sky please. And then this is where all these gods develop. And then it goes on from there. Like Christianity itself there, you talk to any legitimate biblical scholar, they're going to say the Old Testament, there was definitely in the

1:10:14 ↗

Hebrew Bible a few different gods. There's good evidence that there was several gods. But let's hear what Matt actually says here. In the 40s and 50s when people were supposedly abducted by aliens or ran into aliens, they had descriptions of aliens that pretty much uh were varied and often matched the various monsters that you saw in the movies. And after 2001 or after sorry after Close

1:10:41 ↗

Encounters of the the third kind almost all descriptions of aliens became the almond headed you know this >> the the narrative in the culture about what an alien was >> converged >> converged and people were oh this is what I experienced in the same way that >> people will >> now take that thousands thousands of years ago like the example I just gave with rain and

1:11:07 ↗

And cultures start converging on their religious beliefs and their gods and they take all sorts of things from cultures around them and create their ownness from them. The sometimes cameras will catch orbs or a particular lighting effect in a house that is supposedly haunted will be perceived as a ghost as a spiritual you

1:11:33 ↗

know humanoid form. when we in some cases can show that that's actually not the case. In other cases, we have no idea what they necessarily saw. But because the what people understand about spirits and souls and ghosts is in like the zeitgeist of how we think. It's it enters the consciousness as a plausible explanation even if ultimately

1:11:59 ↗

there's no such thing as >> Yeah. But that that explains why they converge. But it doesn't explain why the initial impetus is the attribution of the experiences to something supernatural like to something. See, I'm fair enough. >> I'm not I'm sure that the I'm not convinced that necessarily the the the natural instinct is is to apply it to something supernatural. I think it may be more the case that not only are we pattern recognition machines, but we're the descendants of of people who you

1:12:24 ↗

know how you see faces and everything. >> Yeah, that's a good hypothesis. That's the Yeah. And so you see faces or you anticipate that there's something in the bush out to get you. And when you go and actually investigate and you find there's nothing in the bush out to get you rather than assuming that you might have been mistaken. >> Ha, maybe it's a spirit. >> Yeah. The social psychologists call that the hyperactive agency detector. and and the fact that we we can be, you know, before we had a good understanding, we still have a good understanding of of

1:12:51 ↗

death and the mind and stuff, but if I'm standing here talking to you and I drop over dead, there's a clear [sighs] undeniable difference in me sitting here as an animated being and me laying there as no longer there. And so it seems in natural inference that something that about me has left >> left. >> That doesn't mean that there's actually

1:13:17 ↗

something about me like a soul or whatever that's left. You know, we don't tend to think the same thing when the radio stops working or the or the television stops working. It's not like the man in the TV has left. It's just off. But it seems that those sorts of >> I want to use that analogy because it suggests that whatever is in the TV is coming from an external source and you're definitely not making that argument with regards to the soul.

1:13:43 ↗

>> Well, the TV station isn't in my living room so there's at least some external source sending it. >> But that's exactly my point. Yeah, that's all I you make a case that consciousness isn't exactly in your head either, even though it's localized. I >> So why would I think consciousness is anywhere? >> Matt was just about to say it. You have you cannot show me one thing that is conscious

1:14:10 ↗

that does not all stem from and come from the brain. Without no brain, you're not conscious anymore. No brain, no consciousness. Like that much we do know. You can take away your arm. You could take away your legs. You take away your spleen, your freaking appendix, like whatever.

1:14:39 ↗

Consciousness is still there. Not to mention, you can get into Ramachandran's work about split brain patients and all that other [ __ ] Like sometimes there's two forms of consciousness in the brain depending on what happened with those split bra split brain patients. Like >> where other than my head? Well, how do you account for consciousness?

1:15:09 ↗

>> It's just a bad faith move right there. Like there is no and it's a struggle right now. Physicalism does hold the high majority of consensus. dualism, substance dualism, idealism, pansychism are all different versions, but none of them come close.

1:15:35 ↗

>> Well, I'm not sure that we can account for consciousness. >> This is definitely true. >> But >> yes, >> see, and that's >> I have no reason to think that it's beyond, you know, what the brain produces. >> The fact that something's mysterious doesn't mean that, well, if >> it's okay to say I don't know. And that's the problem with everybody outside of the, you know, atheists, the secular

1:16:01 ↗

humanists, the non-spiritual people, whatever you want to call them. The biggest thing there is the fact that >> something's mysterious. Consciousness isn't just mysterious. It's like really mysterious. It's it's the most mysterious.

1:16:27 ↗

>> Sorry, had to find my thought again. Yes. So, basically, let me just rewind this for a second. >> Doesn't mean that Well, if mysterious consciousness isn't just mysterious, >> it's like really mysterious. It's it's the most mysterious thing. It's not It's not like ordinary mysterious. >> The fact that something is really mysterious. Oh, saying I don't know. The whole I don't know thing is fine. Like we just

1:16:53 ↗

didn't know what caused earthquakes. I think it was what the 50s7s we discovered plate tectonics. Like and this is the thing. Science has been doing this now since the late 1800s in a very fast fashion. I mean you can argue back to Capernicus. You can maybe even argue back to the Greeks. like we're taking I don't knows and then we learn new

1:17:19 ↗

things and then we do experiments and then we get answers to them and then we no longer do not know. It's okay to say I don't know. And religious people don't ever say I don't know >> to the point where I think you and I would agree that >> we don't have an explanation for it. >> Okay. If if there was something like that, we we'll say that it's maybe consciousness. We agree we don't have an explanation or at least a complete one for consciousness >> or even a partial one.

1:17:45 ↗

>> Okay, sure. >> It seems vaguely consciousness brain. >> Really mysterious. >> That's just a bad faith, dude. Show me one [ __ ] thing that's conscious that does not have a brain. It has everything to do with your brain. Now, we don't know the mechanisms outside of that, like what is causing it. And then there's different levels of consciousness like a dog isn't as

1:18:11 ↗

conscious as you know a human like they don't have metacognition as far as we can tell a lot of other animals. Why do we have metal cognition? Well, most scientists believe because it's development of the prefrontal cortex and how much larger it is than everyone else's. Like it takes a lot of brain power. And then where does language lay on that? Because then once you start having language for things, you start separating yourself from the

1:18:37 ↗

environment. That is also building upon that I'm separate from the environment thing. >> Serious. And you and I have no explanation for it. As human beings, we're uncomfortable with saying I don't know. This is something I'm trying to teach people to become more comfortable with is to say I don't know. >> And so when you ask me about consciousness, my answer is I don't know. But for other people, they're so uncomfortable with I don't know that

1:19:03 ↗

they posit an explanation that they cannot justify something that's untestable and unfalsifiable. And that is that there's a ghost in the machine. >> I can't make that leap because there's it it is it is entirely speculation without support. It seems intuitively right because of how we view the world. And yet I would rather say I don't know

1:19:30 ↗

and then continue to explore it because I I worry that by asserting what the explanation is you stop looking for the actual explanation. >> Okay. So you're you made the case that >> real quick because I I seen I had this written down. I'm unmuted. Okay. The overwhelming consensus in neuroscience and philosophy of mind is that consciousness depends entirely on physical brain processes.

1:19:55 ↗

rejecting the receiver external transmission model of dualism though explaining how physical processes give rise to subjective experience that is the hard problem of consciousness and it does remain unresolved at the moment so nobody has an answer to it but just to it's like a god of the gaps just to say

1:20:21 ↗

how do you explain it well okay god Da da da. Huh? It is just it's bad faith. >> Part of the reason that we assume beings is because there's a being that seems lacking in death. >> And that was associated. I had asked the question about why people attribute their mystical experiences to supernatural beings. So we kind of went off on a little bit of a tangent there, but it was related. So we could say,

1:20:47 ↗

well, your idea is something like people personify the soul for obvious reasons, and they also have a hyperactive agency detector. And so it's the combination of whatever mechanisms that produce that that allow them to attribute supernatural personification to the source of mystical experiences. It's something like that. Yeah. Okay. So let let me let me ask you something. We'll get back to that maybe. Um [laughter] >> um let me ask you something about

1:21:14 ↗

consciousness. Can you tell me what what you think about this? Okay. All right. So, this is how it looks to me. I mean, there's lots of ways of thinking about how people interact with the world, but I think this is how we treat ourselves and other people as we see them acting in the world. And so, I would say it's indicative of our deepest belief because I think belief is associated. consciousness appears to me is that it's

1:21:40 ↗

a faculty, let's say, that confronts possibility. We'd call that possibility, well, sometimes possibility, sometimes we call it potential. >> We're getting into some good Petersonisms, >> like your potential, sometimes we call it the future. So, I don't see us as driven deterministically like clocks, which is apparently I think, although I've been accused of misunderstanding Sam Harris before, but I think that's

1:22:06 ↗

the that's the argument that he makes. I see us instead as agents confronting a landscape of possibility and that what consciousness does is enable us to shape that possibility into actuality and we do that with whatever it is that allows us to make decisions. I think that our legal system is basically predicated on the idea that that's true. I think that

1:22:31 ↗

if you treat yourself that way, that works. I think if you treat other people as if that's their basic characteristic and perhaps their value, that you get along with them. And I think that if you organize your society on that presupposition, it appears to be functional. So, so what do you think about the idea of consciousness as confronting a landscape of possibility or potential is

1:22:57 ↗

there something >> I don't trying to think this is the part where he talks a little about about free will. I know Sam Harris got brought up so there's definitely some free will there and then obviously morality. Um, I believe Matt is compatibilist kind of like with Daniel Dennett. Um, rejects libertarian free will.

1:23:28 ↗

I'm not fully sure. There's some more studying and reading I need to do. I may consider myself a compatible, but definitely am more of a determinist at the moment. I don't see I think cho I think choice is an illusion. I don't know. Like you come to a fork in a road and you have to choose between going left or right. Well,

1:23:53 ↗

everything up until that exact moment of you choosing is going to force your choice, affect your choice. And you have no idea what all those things are. So you can't necessarily choose. [clears throat] You can't necessarily choose because that would take you forever to make a choice. So, you go left, but you have no idea why you went left. You can post hawk rationalize why you

1:24:20 ↗

went left. Oh, I went left because, you know, that tree over there reminded me of this or blah blah blah, but you can't possibly know. >> So, I I I don't know that I have that much of an issue with anything in particular that you've said. There's a number of different ways to to frame these things so that people can have a better grasp on it. One of the things I know people struggle with is,

1:24:47 ↗

and we may have to get back to this in a minute. I don't necessarily want to dig in on it just a second, but I would love to talk about it. Um, this idea that absent a god, there's no moral authority. This is a fear that many people have. And when you're talking about viewing consciousness as the way the way you describe consciousness is what I would probably call our agency. >> Okay. >> And while I don't think that we have

1:25:14 ↗

libertarian free will, I'm on record as being a compatibilist along with Dan Dennett. Um but I also had a re another discussion recently. So I'm going to clarify it because of that discussion. I'm fine with the idea that we have a will, that we have desires, that we have that we are an agent uh that is also capable of self-reflection to see what are the consequences of my action moving forward. To me, it does not matter if that is ultimately deterministic like

1:25:40 ↗

clockwork. Um or if there was some something that could trump determinism. Oh, I shouldn't have said Trump. I'm so sorry. uh I if there was something that could actually overcome the the deterministic view that doesn't change to me the fact that you would be the agent responsible for your actions. Now when my when my uh lawn mower acts up um I will sometimes

1:26:09 ↗

anthropomorphically, you know, cuss it out. >> Yeah, it's hard to get rid of those vestigages of religious behavior. But yeah, it is touche. I mean, uh although at least I got rid of them. >> I haven't seen you interact with your lawn mower yet. [applause] >> But at the end, I recognize that the lawn mower is not a thinking agent that is not making decisions. And so that

1:26:34 ↗

that difference between there um is where I would inject the sort of ideas about moral responsibility. the Sam and I had a Sam Harris and I had an argument in Chicago about free will and I was pointing out that uh he could walk over and step off the end of the stage or I could pick him up and carry him and drop him off the stage and at the end the the effect would essentially be the same. But the conflict between those two is everything that I describe as will.

1:27:01 ↗

Whether you want to call it free or not, I think that's what that's what we value. That's what we care about. That's I would be responsible for that action. I would be acting in opposition to what the other agent wanted and I don't know that we have to >> and there would be something hypothetically wrong about that. >> Yes. >> Okay. Okay. Good. So that's close. We can we can get to the morality thing because I think the the next question I had unless you wanted to follow up on

1:27:27 ↗

that >> is a lot of you know like I was saying earlier it seems that you're talking a lot about you're you you haven't addressed the issue and I'm not going to push back on it because I want to move on to some other >> uh of whether or not there is good reason to believe there actually is a god as opposed to whether there are good reasons for people to believe that there actually is a god. Dan Dennett describes >> the >> the difference there once again phenomenology ontology.

1:27:52 ↗

>> Um you know there are people who believe and then there are people who believe in belief that there's value >> and and from what you said here and in some other comments which I'm not going to saddle you with I'm curious >> irrespective of whether there's a god >> what is it that you fear we would lose if people stopped believing that there was a god? Oh. Oh my gosh. Like this answer

1:28:18 ↗

>> believing there was value in belie >> we'd lo we'd lose the metaphoric substrate of our ethos and we'd be lost. >> And so so that's Nietian right there. And this dude loves the talk about Nichzche. But once again, Nietze

1:28:45 ↗

was not saying this in such a sad way. It was somewhat triumphant. He believed that this paved the way for what he called freeth thinkers to now create their own morals and values

1:29:12 ↗

and as I'm going to get into there's some ways to do that. So I I'm a uneducated. So >> I >> But you're wrong about NZA. NZ was right about that for all these people who literally believe in a literal freaking guy up in the sky. And this is outside. I'm not even going

1:29:38 ↗

to get into the shitty morals of the freaking Christian Bible and Christian morality. Like there's a lot of terrible things that don't ever get addressed. But once again, Nietze thought this was also a great thing for a small group of people. >> I really want to know, and I'm not I'm not >> Yeah. >> being a dick. I want to know. >> He's never mentioned that ever. I've listened to more Jordan Peterson

1:30:04 ↗

since like 2014 than probably almost anybody you know and have talked to. never mentions that. >> What you mean by metaphorical substrate? Because saying we're going to lose it. >> So there there's there's the idea when I when I ask what do you think we're going to lose? There's two things. >> One is there's something that you and I would both agree we should try to keep. >> Yeah. >> And there are other things that you and

1:30:31 ↗

I might disagree on whether or not we should keep it. Because when people say to me, oh, you know, if we go down the road with Doski that, you know, uh if there is no God, everything's permissible. Uh, first of all, I don't think that's remotely true because I have >> he makes a pretty vicious case for it and beyond good and evil. >> And despite the fact that it sounds monumentally arrogant. I think I can demolish that case in about two minutes with his secular morality like >> Yeah. And that's again, yes, there we go. Like it's such an arrogant statement

1:30:58 ↗

for him to say in Beyond Good and Evil. Not to mention his damn [ __ ] course on Beyond Good and Evil. He doesn't quote NZ once from Beyond Good and Evil. [clears throat] But there are ways around it. Sam Harris did it and all you have to do is presuppose [ __ ] well-being. And yes, you can say there are some people who are in a condition where maybe they would be better off dead. Those are exceptions.

1:31:25 ↗

There's always exceptions to rules. Like there always is. But it can be done. And you can argue it from a strictly selfish selfish point. I don't want to get stolen from. I don't want to be murdered. So I shouldn't do that to other people. >> Uh but well I think the first part of that statement is right, but not the

1:31:50 ↗

second one. >> And we could find out. But but the thing is there would be two categories of things that you and others might be fearful we would lose. Some of which I might agree we should definitely not lose these things. >> Yeah. >> Others I might be absolutely fine with losing >> like it that it's wrong to throw Sam Harris off a stage. >> Yeah. I I don't plan on doing that. >> Cross my mind at one point.

1:32:16 ↗

>> We both agreed that that was probably wrong. Yes. >> So, okay. So, that's good. >> Probably. >> Yeah. >> See, I I'm a situational e ethicist and so there might be situations. If the stage were on fire, throwing Sam off would be the best thing I could do for him. >> So, what [snorts] do you think? What do you think we're likely to lose? What bothered you? And when you say metaphor uh metaphorical substrate, >> I probably just monumentally ignorant,

1:32:42 ↗

but I really don't think I have a good understanding of what you mean. >> Well, there's levels of thought. I mean, every thought structure, let's say, every belief structure is multi-levelled, like a piece of music. and and there's the there's the word in a phrase and then there's the phrase and then there's the sentence and then there's the paragraph and then there's the sequence of paragraphs within which the paragraphs are uttered and then there's

1:33:08 ↗

a broader context of interpretation within which all of that is interpreted and then there's our emotional and motivational similarity and then there's our embodiment in the world and all of those things are operative at all times when we're understanding ing one another. And as you move outside the realm of the linguistic, like the paragraph level, let's say, into the realm of the emotional and motivational and embodiment and embodied, you also

1:33:33 ↗

move into the metaphorical. And the metaphorical is structured in a particular way. And this is quite well documented by the way. >> It it is >> I mean, if you look at how >> hold on >> the hemispheres interact. So the left hemisphere broadly speaking broadly speaking and I'm not oversimplifying this except that we don't have much time is linguistic but the linguistic

1:33:59 ↗

utterances are understood in the context provided more by the right hemisphere which is non-verbal and which attends to things like the music of language. And so at the bottom of a linguistic structure there's something that's extra linguistic and it tends to take form in metaphor and narrative and drama and that sort of thing. And the religious landscape is the cool.

1:34:24 ↗

I agree with a lot of that. But what he starts doing in cognitive neuroscience shows a lot of what Peterson just said there to be true. I just this now he's calling it the religious landscape. Why why start using those terms? >> Narrative metaphor drama landscape and

1:34:52 ↗

if you disrupt it then you blow apart the widest possible context within which the specific utterances are rendered comprehensible. >> Okay. So I followed all that shockingly. Um anytime you were talking about science and hemispheres and all this other stuff. So when you're talking about the broader context, if we lose belief in a god, we lose that

1:35:17 ↗

metaphorical substrate that is the broader context in which we evaluate these narratives. >> Yeah. That that really that really grinds them into our bodies that that makes them things we believe rather than just think. >> Sure. But >> see, you didn't you didn't just think that it was wrong to throw Sam off the off the off the uh >> stage. God, Sam's going to be pissed when he >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's okay. >> Well, so so

1:35:47 ↗

>> see there's a difference between thinking something and believing it because to believe it, it has to be thought incarnated in some sense. It has to be >> when I talk about it, belief is the state of being convinced that a proposition is true or likely true. It's every everything that I try to do, I I tend to view in the form of propositional reasoning. Um, so when we talk about the narrative, >> yeah, that's a problem by the way. Okay. >> Yeah. Well, it's you can't reduce the

1:36:12 ↗

world to set of propositions. >> Why not? >> Oh, look, >> show me something that is true in the world that is not a proposition >> that that you cannot >> stable proposition. >> Something that is demonstrabably true that I could not put in a proposition. >> Oh, that's that's easy. You sure you want to go there? >> I'm not afraid of anything. >> Okay. Okay.

1:36:37 ↗

If I'm wrong, I want to know I'm wrong. But I I'm trying to for years I had this thing going where people would say, "Oh," and this is kind of what we're getting at from a different angle. I would say they would be afraid of what we would lose if we lost religion. And I basically said, "Demonstrate to me any benefit." >> Oh, you'd lose art and poetry and drama and narrative story. >> What a crazy [ __ ] statement to say.

1:37:03 ↗

>> Are there are there no godless artists and poets? They think they are >> artists and poets who think they're godless. >> So, we might have crossed over into a problem area because I I don't actually >> I can't draw for crap. Although I do draw during the show. Um, >> but one of the individuals who came to the show the other night handed me

1:37:28 ↗

something that she had spent a great deal of time drawing. She's a wonderful artist. I'm very grateful to get it. And um you know, while I pretend to read minds on stage, I I constantly acknowledge that I can't actually read minds. So I can't tell you whether or not she actually believes in a god. But I can tell you that I actually don't believe in a god. And I could write >> you do. >> Huh? >> But you act like you do. That's why you

1:37:53 ↗

didn't say Sam off the stage. >> No. Now you're making a claim. Okay. So I'm telling you I don't believe there's a god. And your response to that is, I really do because I have a moral sense, but my moral sense is utterly >> without any appeal to a god >> explicitly or implicitly. >> Uh maybe the >> that's not so obvious.

1:38:18 ↗

>> Okay. It's really >> because you regard you regard Sam Harris as an implicitly valuable entity because otherwise you just throw him off the stage. And then the question is well just exactly why is he an implicitly valuable entity? I don't >> because I wouldn't want to get thrown off the [ __ ] stage. And I guess here's a good time. I was going to We got just a few more sections left. We're almost done here. I just

1:38:44 ↗

want to share real quickly the premises, the syllogism for objective morals. It comes from Gorthian ethics and Arisian virtue ethics. Um, I don't know if uh this guy got it from someone else, but alle allegedly Ian does a great job of talking about this way better than I will. I'm just going to kind of res

1:39:09 ↗

list off these premises real quick. And it basically logic and then virtue ethics. Basically, so premise one, human beings are unavoidably human beings are unavoidably agents who perform purposeful goal directed actions. Premise two, to pursue or achieve any goal whatsoever, an agent logically

1:39:34 ↗

requires two generic conditions, freedom, autonomy, and well-being. Premise three. Because freedom and well-being are necessary to achieve chosen goals, an agent logically asserts that they ought to have these conditions and the others ought not to interfere with them, thereby claiming a right to freedom and well-being. Premise four, the underlying ground or sufficient condition for an agent asserting this

1:40:02 ↗

right is simply the fact that they are an agent. that it's self-evident that an agent is an agent essentially like these are the underlying conditions. Premise five. If agency itself is sufficient for an individual to claim a right to freedom and well-being, then by the law of non-contradiction, agency itself must be sufficient for all agents to possess those same rights.

1:40:29 ↗

Conclusion: Therefore, all agents objectively possess a right to freedom and well-being, and any action that violates another agent's freedom or well-being involves a logical self-contradiction, and contradictions can't exist. Like boom, that's it. Like right there. And again, like I said earlier, you can argue from a selfish point of view of I don't want people to do these things to me. I'm not

1:40:56 ↗

going to do them to them. Like this isn't some profound thing. You don't think people back in the ancient near east didn't think about this [ __ ] when they were writing their myths? Like come on, man. Get it together, Jordan. >> What's your metaphysics of that? I don't think he's implicitly valuable in the

1:41:21 ↗

sense in the [cheering] I don't think he's I don't think he's implicitly valuable in the sense that the universe has in in implied that there's something explicit about for me morality is is far simpler than some people >> wait you sounded doubtful about that you know that like you're the mind reader you've been well you well maybe >> because you've already you've already suggested that despite me sitting here

1:41:47 ↗

and having talked about this for decades uh that I don't believe in God that I actually do because I have a moral code. But my moral code, which I've >> Well, I was more specific. I I said it was because you didn't want to throw Sam off the stage. >> You didn't You didn't even attempt to ask me why I didn't throw Sam off the stage. Instead, you went to why do you think has Sam has implicit value? Because it seems that in your narrative, >> that's the only justification. >> Well, maybe you were afraid of being

1:42:12 ↗

punished. >> I think you No. Oh, >> I think you can have a perfectly acceptable foundation for secular morality, even if it fundamentally centers around selfishness. >> I'd rather not be thrown off the stage. It's in my best interest to encourage that sort of understanding in others. And therefore, I will not throw him off the stage. I would rather not have my stuff stolen. And it's in my best interest to encourage others not to do that. So, I will not steal stuff. And I

1:42:39 ↗

will work with others to ensure that the people who steal stuff are punished. It is a in a virtually pragmatic uh moral system. >> Why do you think it's not in your best interest to have stuff stolen from you or to be thrown off the stage? >> Why is it not in my best interest? >> Yeah. No. No. You know, you don't you don't get to think, "Oh, that's self-evident." It's like nothing's self-evident to the skeptic. Let's keep that in mind. >> Oh my gosh.

1:43:06 ↗

That's just such a snobby [ __ ] bad because now you're not talking about methodological skepticism. You're going into the Decart hard salopsis skepticism once again. It's another retreat like well so uh [applause]

1:43:32 ↗

because if we're going to get skeptical here, we might as well go all the way. For for for Sam and I, the foundations, and we're not the only ones, but >> that's not what all skepticism is, Jordan. There's different forms of skepticism, and you know that. You have to know that because you're way [ __ ] smarter than I am. That's why that's what pisses me off. Like, he's not a dumb typical Christian apologist or especially like a presupp.

1:43:59 ↗

Oh my god, they're the worst. But like, come on, dude. We're not trying to do this Decart skepticism of just keep questioning everything forever and ever and ever and ever and never do anything or never trust like no it's not >> but I I tend to reference Sam just because if I say this then somebody will say well that's exactly what Sam Harris says except that you know I was given this lecture before he wrote his book but uh but his book is better than my

1:44:25 ↗

lecture so read his book when I talk about this I'm talking about well-being is the language that Sam uses. I don't >> sad >> I don't care whether or not somebody else considers that morality >> at I would think at a minimum would you and I agree that >> that whole well-being thing man as a basis for a metaphysics that's just a non >> we're not basing metaphysics on it >> Sam is >> no he's not

1:44:51 ↗

>> yes he is because he's out to maximize well >> you can take it up with Sam >> well okay sorry do you think you think I'm wrong about that claim I that's what I understood >> I don't think Sam's saying anything metaphysical about it I think so here's the thing we are physical Well, it's his fundamental claim. So, it's sort of at the basis of his ethics. And so, he says, well, we should work to maximize people's well-being or at least to more. He does a bit more than that because he says we should minimize suffering. >> He's not maximize minimize in this sense

1:45:19 ↗

of s simple consequentialism. Let me do this. >> Okay. We're phys physical beings in a physical universe and the laws that dictate how things work in the universe. They are the ultimate arbiters of what is or isn't in our best interest whether we know it or not. So for example, so far as I can tell >> then why do you need free will? >> I don't I don't >> don't need >> why do you believe in it then? Why do you why do you attribute agency to

1:45:44 ↗

things if the laws of the universe can >> get to that one point? >> Well, but there was a contradiction. Free will isn't free will isn't relevant to this. >> It is if the laws of the universe are what are dictating what's good for us. >> No, because if you chop off my head, that is clearly not good for me. And it doesn't matter whether it was an act of free will or if it was my lawn mower. >> It's clearly not good for you because

1:46:09 ↗

you think you're valuable and worth preserving. >> Yes. >> Okay, that's the issue. Why do you think you're valuable and worth preserving? Because I am the descendants of people who thought they were valuable and worth dis worth preserving and the ones who didn't think that have killed themselves. But this is not a statement about this is not a statement about intrinsic value. >> I I don't know. Yes. Yes. I think it is. Okay. Okay. But I think it is

1:46:35 ↗

>> okay. [laughter] it. The reason that we talk about this in terms of well-being is because irrespective of whether or not I care about well-being, there are facts about well-being. >> Sure, let's hear them, man. Line those suckers up. >> If you chop off my head, it's in contradiction to my wellbeing. I mean, that but the point >> No, I wasn't willing to grant that, actually. >> Okay. >> I'm saying that's a metaphysical presupposition.

1:47:02 ↗

>> You're just saying I have to accept that. >> No, I'm not I'm not telling you at all what to accept. Sure, you are. You're saying that I'm trying to explain what my position is. >> Okay. But but you said that that wouldn't be in accordance with your well-being. Okay. That's a metaphysical statement or philosophical statement. It's not an obvious fact >> that chopping off somebody's head is contrary to their wellbeing. It >> depends on how you define well-being. >> You must have been watching a different

1:47:28 ↗

debate, my friend. >> Sure. >> Yeah. But it matters. >> But if you define well-being as this glass of water, we're no longer talking about the same thing. Well, you can define wellbeing. That's fine. That's what I'm waiting for. >> This is So, this is what I'm >> You can't do it. You can't define wellbeing. It's >> Well, then why should I try? Certainly can't do it if you keep telling me I can't do it. >> Okay. Sorry. Okay. I'll back off. I'll back off. There's a Go ahead. I'm I'm I'm all ears. >> So, the primary objection to Minus AM's

1:47:56 ↗

position that keeps coming back is why should anybody care about well-being? and we both will acknowledge that this is and in fact a subjective preference. There are people who are going to care about wellbeing. There are people who aren't. The second objection is that well-being is not clearly defined. Both of us have acknowledged this. It's not as if we're saying we have all the answers to uh how to go about living a better life. We're just saying that however we're going to define well-being, which is

1:48:24 ↗

I I say you can start with a couple of foundations. You could start with death is preferable to life, but you don't get very far that way. >> Stop suffering. >> Well, no, I'm saying you could start with death is preferable to life, >> but you don't get very far that way because >> Yeah, you do. You stop suffering. You just die. >> Yes. >> Right. So, you can start with the presupposition. >> Except that when you're dead, you're not being. So, there's no well-being.

1:48:51 ↗

No. Well, that's [applause] >> if >> that's not that's not necessarily >> if we're looking for the best. >> No, I don't think it did. I think that John Hopkins study itself is a great study, but it doesn't when Jordan's saying that it was the only way to quit smoking was absolutely

1:49:18 ↗

ridiculous. It doesn't say that whatsoever in the study also while you're here and I appreciate you being here. Is the sound pretty good here? Because I'm just trying to been testing stuff. This is only like my third live stream ever. >> [clears throat]

1:49:50 ↗

>> things about our life. You can't say death is better. >> Yeah, you can. >> Well, I know that you can say it. >> People do all the time. They do. No, look, >> they can express their preference, but their preference can be wrong. How can it possibly be better for your life if you're dead? What if you like are a terminal burn victim with cancer? >> I am see this is the point that I was

1:50:15 ↗

getting to. I am perfectly fine with the idea that for certain instances there may be occasions that death is preferable to an individual over life. But when we're speaking in broader terms, if we're talking about let's create the best society we can, let's create the best quality of life we can for people, death is not that. >> No. And I I think there's great reasons to use mushrooms and everything in

1:50:43 ↗

therapy to help people quit addictions and have these so-called mystical experiences. What Matt was arguing is there's a difference between phenomenology and ontology. And then the phenomenology that people have when they have those mystical experiences does not prove at all that those mystical experiences are ontological. And there's really no way to do that because it's all subjective

1:51:12 ↗

>> across the board. It that doesn't mean that there aren't individual exceptions. So the foundations that I that I started with, you could start with death is better than life, but blah blah blah. If you start with life is generally preferable to death, health is generally preferable to sickness. Happiness is generally preferable to sadness. None of these are absolute locked in stone rules. from those things. >> Okay. So, if you start with them. >> Yes. If you start, >> you're not skeptical about those claims. >> Wow. >> Well, I'm asking, >> you know, I came out and said that I

1:51:39 ↗

wasn't going to be trying to straw man you left and right. And now every time I say something, you're like, "Oh, so you're not skeptical about that?" >> It is. That part kills me because again, Jordan knows Matt is talking about methodological skepticism, but keeps taking it back to this hard salypism thing. all the time. And it's a very not calling Jordan a Christian

1:52:04 ↗

apologetic, but it's a Christian apologetic move all the time. Like, how do you know anything if you're skeptical about so much? How do you know anything? It's absolutely maddening. >> Well, I'm trying to >> No, sorry. I'm not trying to attack you. I'm trying to understand where your argument begins. >> Well, it seems odd that you would come out with so you're not skeptical about that. >> Well, that's a question. while I'm on my skepticism tour. While I'm in >> It's cuz science can't

1:52:37 ↗

>> mid-sentence to describe that these are the general >> and until we have a way to actually study those mystical experiences and phenomenological experiences, the correct thing to say is I don't know.

1:53:08 ↗

foundations that you start with. >> Okay, that's what I was asking. Those are okay. So, but what you're saying if you're saying correct me if I'm wrong. I'm not trying to be difficult. >> You're saying that those are your starting positions. Those are the things that you accept. I'm saying faith. >> No. >> Oh, you have a rationale for them. >> Yes. >> Let's hear it. >> You already have. Life is generally preferable to death because we're talking about our life and

1:53:34 ↗

death is generally not in the interest of the living. It can be on exception. This is the point that I was getting to. So you could start with those found. You could start with any three that you found. You could pick three arbitrary foundations. And the one aspect that makes a secular moral system distinct from religious pronouncements and divine command theory and those sorts of things is that the the secular moral system has as its goal

1:54:00 ↗

the object of getting better at getting better. Which means if you find out that one of your foundations is wrong or in conflict with something else, you can now change that. You could start with death is preferable to life and then when you find out that it's not working that well, you change that foundation. I think that these foundations based on the evidence of how people tend to live their lives and what they care about are a good set of three. There could be better ones that somebody come up with. I'm open to revision on any of these at

1:54:26 ↗

any time. But to say that I'm not skeptical about them is exactly the opposite of what I am because skepticism is about I'm not going to accept something as true without good reason. And it's about being willing to being open to revision should there be evidence. If you and I agree that we care about a good life. Good life isn't very well defined. And we may have different ideas about what good life is. But if we could actually just sit here

1:54:52 ↗

and take notes, you know, I think that we'd come across maybe a handful of things that we would agree would make for a good life. If we take those and compare them to the foundations of a secular moral system like what I'm describing, we can determine non-subjectively whether or not what we've the list we've come up with are consist

1:56:37 ↗

Thank you. [laughter] Done that three times already. Um I'm a rookie over here. Um I can definitely say like I totally agree. People take psychedelics and have crazy experiences. They've changed my life. in very much ways. I' I would say I would what I would consider the word mystical. I've definitely have had mystical experiences. I've taken seven and a half grams a couple times, which I don't

1:57:04 ↗

recommend to the point where I have lost sense of I and me and subjective anything, but I don't bring anything out of that supernatural. If you're interested, man, and can message me on here. I think my email is available. I'll make sure it is in my channel, I would love to bring up I'm trying to get people to start having

1:57:30 ↗

conversations like this. So, and I'm not a [ __ ] debater either. I genuinely just enjoy the conversations instantly approachable by that from that foundation. And we can do that for religious moralities as well. the the analogy that I've used in the past is is for example a game of chess. Um there's nothing about the universe that requires that we care about chess or care about the rules of chess. The rules of chess are arbitrary. Somebody made them up. We

1:57:56 ↗

changed them. We added on patant. We added castling. We need things like that. We have the rules of chess. We don't always know what the best move is. But if the goal of the game is to win or at a minimum not lose, then we can analyze the moves with respect to the consequences and with respect to the goal of winning and determine which moves are better and which moves are worse. That is what a secular moral system does because it allows revision. Whereas religious systems don't allow

1:58:23 ↗

for revision. There's not a Bible 3.0. There's not a Quran 2.0. There's no new revelation from God to say, "Hey, uh, you know, I said all this stuff about slavery. and now I'm opposed to it. Or, hey, you know, I was really down on homosexuals, but now I'm okay with it. Hey. Uh, you know when I said

1:59:01 ↗

Well, I think the biggest thing atheists aren't usually talking to people who who are not who they're usually talking I should say almost always talking to people who believe the Bible is inherent and literally true like so I would definitely be interested

1:59:26 ↗

in what you mean by mystical experience I mean I usually do kind of agree with Jordan as far as meaning of awe and you feel this feeling of transcendence said that here's what caused diseases or that you were unclean and shouldn't enter the temple. Uh I'm act all those things are actually wrong. The germ theory of disease is right and none of

1:59:52 ↗

that's been come out. >> Well, there is kind of a Bible 2.0. That was the New Testament, right? Well, that is that is the update for >> Well, the problem with that, Jordan, is we have no reason to believe the New Testament is true. >> For the Christians, uh except that it's worse than >> I would agree it's lowhanging fruit. But

2:00:19 ↗

the problem is these people are voting. These people actively hate homosexuals and are misogynists. And that's not all Christians, but that's a any the vast majority of Christians who believe the Bible is inherent vote on these things. And the reason why we're in this position in the United States, I don't know what country you're

2:00:45 ↗

in, but is because a bunch of conservative Christians just vote for people on the right no matter what >> in the the first one. >> Well, that that's not exactly the point. The point is there was an update. So, >> well, >> okay. So, >> in the update, it's not like Jesus came along and said, "Hey, in Exodus 21, where I was saying you could have slaves and beat them, we got that wrong or you got that wrong." That correction is

2:01:11 ↗

never given. That that thing about, you know, in Leviticus where we point out that women are worth twothirds of that of a man. We got that wrong. None of that is corrected. In fact, the reason I say it got worse, although cool. I'm going to leave my uh email in the chat for you because it's not like anybody else is watching and I'm popular and people are going to just spam me.

2:01:47 ↗

But send me an email for sure. I would love to get people up. I need to get better at uh bringing guests on here on OBS anyway as I kind of continue this whatever it is I'm doing. So, I didn't know we were going to go down the the biblical route tonight. Is that if you if you look at Jewish

2:02:12 ↗

tradition, when you're dead, you sleep with your father. >> Sorry, my dumb ass spelled that wrong. Hold on. There we go. I can spell [clears throat]

2:02:56 ↗

Yeah, I would love to chat about uh your thoughts on um that John Hopkins study. I've only glanced at it a few times, but um I mean I've heard it brought up a ton of time when I was way back in the whole following what's his name from Maps. the Rick Dablin, I believe his name is [clears throat]

2:03:30 ↗

there's no real clear notion of an afterlife. And then with the introduction of the New Testament, what you get is infinite torture and punishment for finite crimes, which is immoral. >> All right. So I don't >> I mean my biggest problem with Peterson is taking the the neuroscience and then he sprinkles these religious and spiritual language over it

2:03:58 ↗

which is ridiculous. I mean a lot of uh I'm trying to find the book here. I got it here somewhere. almost all of I don't know if you ever read or heard this book Peterson's mentioned before the ecological approach for visual perception which basically sums up all of Peterson's ideas about you know perception and how we go out into the world and have hierarchies and we visualize things and stuff like that.

2:04:24 ↗

So that drives me nuts about Peterson. I I feel like he's over complicated >> want to go down that rabbit hole at the moment. Although I'd be perfectly happy to do it, you know, if we

2:04:59 ↗

All right.

2:06:29 ↗

Awesome. Yeah, send me that email. I would love it. Uh, yeah. One of my biggest complaints why I really stopped listening to a lot of Peterson was his misrepresentations of Frederick

2:06:56 ↗

Nietze drove me nuts. And I thought most of that was to continue his Christian agenda because that's where vast majority of his money comes from. So yeah, let's email because I'm wrapping this up. Um, email me and then we can kind of narrow down a few of these topics and we can just kind of talk about them. We'll figure out a good time. Thanks for uh popping in here. Did

2:07:22 ↗

it just randomly pop up on your feed? and doing those call-in shows are no matter who you're calling in on and

2:07:49 ↗

what side you're on, whoever's on the other side of it has such complete control. And it if they want to control the narrative, they can, which gets frustrating sometimes. Oh, good. because I'm glad I put the tags on there. So, but yeah, I would definitely consider myself a soft atheist at the moment,

2:08:15 ↗

but kind of like what we touched on before is, you know, you talked about it being low hanging fruit, which I don't disagree with you. It's more so that all these people are taking the rights of other people because they think it's a good thing. So, Yeah. And I don't have like once you get

2:08:41 ↗

an audience too, people are always trying to uh you know, you do it more for the audience at that point like when Dilla Hunty gets, you know, all pissed off and angry and yelling and [ __ ] So, it's entertaining when it's a person you agree with. But awesome. I appreciate it. I will uh email you back here shortly.