ARTICLE

"The Antichrist, COVID, and Mamdani Walk Into a Sermon..."

"The Antichrist, COVID, and Mamdani Walk Into a Sermon..." cover

* the following was sparked by a sermon I heard given online by a former youth pastor of mine when I was in the 7th-8th grade. Give it a listen here.


Before I get into the weeds of biblical exegesis and culture war diagnostics, let me be clear: I owe the person whom will be discussed in the following text much thanks for how he helped me a few years after my siblings death and there’s a part of me that will always be grateful for that. But gratitude doesn’t mean I have to ignore what has now become a creepy ass cult who wouldn’t know a peer reviewed study if it came up and lit there dumb ass bible on fire.

The one day I logged into Facebook for work and before I could switch to the business account I quickly seen a post from the lead pastor from the church “The Well Buffalo”, Darrick Castronova, pop up. The post was about the late “great” Charlie Kirk. Yes… the Charlie Kirk who only debated young college kids in order to get his “got-you-moment-clips” for his ~84 million dollar company… but maybe more on that at a later date. This post lead me down a rabbit hole; social media posts, background and education, and eventually to sermons The first one to stick out to me was the one from November 16th titled “1st & 2nd Thessalonians: The Gospel For The Last Days”.

Suddenly, a letter to a panicked Greek church in the first century becomes a sermon about vaccines, socialism, AI, and your cousin’s TikTok account.

What happened that day wasn’t just a Bible study. It was a live demonstration of how Christians, and to be slightly more specific, American evangelicalism can take one of the most cryptic, context-bound, and debated passages in the New Testament (2 Thessalonians 2:1–12) and turn it into a weaponized prophecy chart for the culture war. Darrick didn’t just “interpret” the text. He rebuilt it, brick by brick, into a 19th-century American end-times timeline, then welded that timeline to COVID politics, “wokeness,” gender panic, and a soundbite from the new NYC mayor Zoran Mamdani. Suddenly, a letter to a panicked Greek church in the first century becomes a sermon about vaccines, socialism, AI, and your cousin’s TikTok account.

To put it bluntly… Darrick’s brain has been broken by the kind of theology that doesn’t just take the Bible seriously, it takes it literally, systematizes it, and uses it as the blueprint for a very tight-knit, cult-like community. I don’t say that lightly. I say it because what I’m seeing is a move away from open, critical engagement and toward a bunker mentality where dissent is a threat and complexity is the enemy.

“At SBTS every faculty member has to sign a statement saying they’ll never teach anything that contradicts the official doctrine. They’ll teach you Greek and Hebrew, sure, maybe, possibly, but only so long as you never use those tools to challenge the party line.”

If you know a tiny bit about seminaries, I am sure that means you’ve heard that some explicitly require students and faculty to affirm the inerrancy of Scripture as part of their doctrinal or employment statements. This is most common in conservative evangelical and fundamentalist schools. The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (SBTS), the seminary Darrick attended, is the Ivy League of conservative evangelical seminaries. It’s fully accredited, staffed by PhDs, and absolutely committed to the inerrancy of the Bible. But here’s the catch: every faculty member has to sign a statement saying they’ll never teach anything that contradicts the official doctrine. They’ll teach you Greek and Hebrew, sure, but only so long as you never use those tools to challenge the party line. In the wider academic world, SBTS is respected for its technical rigor but gently side-eyed for its confessional straitjacket: you can ask any question, as long as you already know the answer is “the Bible is always right.” In short, it’s a place designed not to produce atheists, but to ensure nobody ever becomes one by accident.

That being said, you can bet Darrick’s sermon isn’t going to be a nuanced exploration of the historical Jesus or a deep dive into textual criticism. It’s going to be a prophecy chart, a warning about the dangers of “woke” culture, and a call to circle the wagons around the last “true” believers. And if you’re not on board, well, you’re either deceived or part of the problem.

This isn’t just about “attacking a pastor.” It’s about exposing how ambiguity gets repackaged as certainty, how ancient ancient near east texts get hijacked for modern ideological battles, and how sermons like this one don’t just interpret; they overwrite, they import, and they smuggle in a whole universe of assumptions that have nothing to do with the original text. It’s the logical outcome of a system that values certainty over curiosity, loyalty over inquiry, and conformity over honest wrestling. I am starting to struggle with the sitting back quietly while people build “communities” that look less like a church and more like a bunker.

The rest of this article is more of a bulleted list where Darrick “misses the mark” (see what I did there?). I have also attached a transcript of the sermon that was spoken at the pulpit on November 16th at The Well Buffalo. You can also listen to the sermon on The Well’s website, also linked below.


Part I – What the Sermon Claims

The entire sermon is built around a single anxiety:

“The Thessalonians were afraid they missed the rapture.”

From there, Derrick spins out a fully-formed prophecy chart:

  • A pre-tribulation rapture (church gets zapped out before things get bad)

  • A seven-year tribulation, split into two 3.5-year halves

  • A future global dictator called the Antichrist

  • A government that deceives people through fear

  • The moral collapse of society as “the apostasy”

  • God sending delusion on unbelievers

  • And, most importantly, a warning that America is sliding toward the Antichrist through:

    • COVID compliance

    • “Government as religion”

    • Progressive politics

    • The new NYC mayor

    • Modern debates on gender, reproduction, and social ethics

This isn’t a caricature. These are direct claims, sometimes verbatim. He even plays a clip of the NYC mayor saying government should care about every problem, then jumps in with:

“Church, that’s not God. The government is becoming the new religion.”

He links all this to people “falling away,” AI, the internet, gender “confusion,” and COVID restrictions. These aren’t “illustrations.” They’re framed as literal fulfillments of prophecy and signs of the coming Antichrist.

Let’s compare this to what the text actually says.


Part II – What 2 Thessalonians 2 Actually Says (and Doesn’t Say)

1. The “Day of the Lord”

The passage is a response to a panic:

Somebody told the Thessalonian church the day of the Lord had already happened.

Paul (or whoever wrote the letter) says:

  • No, it hasn’t happened yet.

  • Two things have to happen first:

    1. A rebellion (“apostasia”)

    2. The revealing of the “man of lawlessness”

What’s missing?

  • No “seven-year tribulation”

  • No “pre-tribulation rapture”

  • No “global government”

  • No “timeline split into two 3.5-year halves”

All those are imports from later theology, not from this text.


2. The “Apostasy” / Rebellion

The Greek word “apostasia” means:

  • Rebellion

  • Defection

  • Political revolt

  • Religious falling away

What it does not mean:

  • A global, end-times, 21st-century deconstruction movement

  • Western society questioning gender

  • AI or technology

  • People being “confused about marriage, reproduction, and the future”

The text says nothing about these modern issues.

Most scholars think the “apostasia” refers to:

  • A local crisis of faith

  • Persecution under Roman rule

  • A schism within the Thessalonian community

  • Or a general end-times rebellion, already at work in the first century.


3. The “Man of Lawlessness”

What the sermon claims:

“This is the Antichrist: a future global dictator who rules the world, sits in the temple, and is defeated at Armageddon.”

What the text actually says:

  • The term “Antichrist” is not used here.

  • The only place “Antichrist” appears is 1–2 John, and there it refers to “many antichrists… who deny that Jesus is the Christ.”

  • The text never names the figure.

  • The text never links him to Revelation’s Beast.

  • The text never mentions Armageddon.

  • The text never says he rules the whole world.

Critical scholars note that the “man of lawlessness” could refer to:

  • A Roman emperor (Caligula, Nero, Domitian)

  • Imperial cult officials

  • A symbolic eschatological enemy

  • Or an unknown figure meaningful only to the Thessalonians

There is no scholarly consensus that he is a single future world dictator.

That idea is imported from:

  • John Nelson Darby (1830s)

  • The Scofield Reference Bible (early 1900s)

  • The Left Behind tradition (1990s)

It was not imported by Paul.


4. The “Restrainer”

Paul says:

“You know what is restraining him now.”

“He who restrains will do so until he is removed.”

The sermon confidently identifies the restrainer as:

  • The Holy Spirit

  • Or the church

  • Or God’s sovereign timeline

  • And ties its removal to the tribulation calendar

But scholars unanimously point out:

We have no idea who or what the restrainer is.

Serious academic proposals include:

  • The Roman Empire

  • The emperor himself

  • An angelic power

  • Divine decree

  • The preaching of the gospel

  • Michael the archangel

But the truth is:

We don’t know, because Paul never tells us.

He assumes the Thessalonians know, but we don’t. We weren’t there.

This is a glaring gap that modern prophecy sermons simply and conveniently overlook.


5. “God Sends Them a Strong Delusion”

The passage says God will actively deceive people so they “believe what is false.”

The sermon reframes this as:

  • “God is good in all of it.”

  • “This is done in love.”

  • “It’s not that God doesn’t care—He loves us.”

This is not exegesis; it is moral and theological reframing.

Critical scholars point out the obvious tension:

  • The text depicts God intentionally deceiving people into condemnation.

  • This is part of a broader biblical pattern (e.g., hardening Pharaoh).

Sweeping this under “love” without addressing the ethical implications is a pastoral decision, most certainly not an exegetical one.


Part III – The Pre-Trib Rapture Problem

The sermon takes for granted:

“You won’t be here. Believers will be raptured before the tribulation.”

But:

  • The pre-trib rapture does not appear in any first-century text.

  • No church father taught it.

  • No early Christian writer taught it.

  • No historical scholar sees it in 1 Thessalonians 4.

Even conservative academic theologians acknowledge that:

The pre-trib rapture arose in the 1830s.

That means the sermon is not interpreting Paul; it’s interpreting Darby and reading him into Paul.


Part IV – How the Sermon Translates Paul Into American Politics

This is the most striking—and telling—part of the whole sermon.

1. COVID as Prophetic Conditioning

He says COVID was proof that:

  • People will obey anything if they’re scared

  • “The government became a religion”

  • “The government will use fear just like the Antichrist will”

This is political commentary wearing apocalyptic clothing.

It’s not exegesis; it’s a culture war sermon in a Bible costume.

2. Government = Religion

He plays the NYC mayor saying:

“No problem too big for government to solve…”

And responds:

“Church, that’s not God. The government is becoming the new religion.”

In biblical exegesis, this is irrelevant…. but in politics….this is red meat.

3. Progressive Social Ethics as “Apostasy”

He lists:

  • Gender

  • Sexuality

  • Reproduction

  • Marriage

  • Social welfare

  • AI

  • The internet

and says all of this is part of the end-times falling away.

But these have nothing to do with 2 Thessalonians.

This is simply the culture war being slid under the door of an ancient apocalyptic letter[1].

4. “Communist Socialist Muslim Mayor”

He describes the new mayor as:

  • Socialist

  • Communist

  • Muslim

  • Dangerous

And folds this into the sermon as if it’s part of prophetic fulfillment.

This is not biblical interpretation.

It is tribal identity politics using Scripture as a megaphone.


Part V – So, What Do The Experts Say?

1. Authorship

  • 2 Thessalonians is debated; many scholars see it as pseudonymous.

  • Its eschatology is more structured and delayed than 1 Thessalonians.

  • It may be written to address early Christians disappointed by Jesus’ delayed return[1].

2. Genre

This is apocalyptic rhetoric, not a blueprint.

It uses:

  • Symbols

  • Enigmatic figures

  • Cosmic language

  • Typology

Apocalyptic texts are not meant to be chronologically mapped onto modern politics.

3. No Unified “Antichrist” Doctrine

There are multiple, conflicting models in the NT:

  • 1 John: many antichrists already here

  • 2 Thessalonians: a mysterious man of lawlessness

  • Revelation: a beast, a false prophet, and a dragon

  • Synoptics: false prophets and messiahs

  • Paul: “the mystery of lawlessness already at work”

None of these require a single dictator ruling a global government in 2025.

4. No Seven-Year Tribulation

This is a product of Darbyite dispensationalism, not the NT.

5. Apostasy = Flexible Term

Nothing in the text identifies it with modern progressive politics.

6. Restrainer = Historical Mystery

No scholar claims to know for sure.

Pastors pretend they know for sure.


Conclusion: Why This Matters

This isn’t just about a sermon, a pastor, a Charlie Kirk supporter, or even the fact that I believe there is very little evidence that the New Testament Authors could even read classical Hebrew (*not too mention all the failed prophecies, slavery, sexism, and baby murder).

It isn’t just about the fact that the majority of right-winged-christian-conservative cults who, just a few years ago, accused the “far left” of being lost in a post-modern ideological worldview have now become the poster child of anti-intellectualism, anti-science, and anti-facts.

It’s about how modern Christians interpret the Bible and know nothing about any other ancient near east belief systems. When you start with a prophecy chart, then search for verses to backfill it, guess what? You stop doing exegesis and start doing reverse engineering. And when you then layer political anxiety on top of that, you end up with a theology that is:

  • Historically inaccurate

  • Textually unsupported

  • Politically convenient

  • Emotionally manipulative

The tragedy is that the Bible contains enough contradictions, ambiguities, and apocalyptic weirdness on its own. It doesn’t need help. But sermons like this don’t just interpret the text, they rewrite it into an American story about COVID, Democrats, socialism, gender debates, and the government replacing God.

Outro

This series exists to expose shitty belief systems, the psychological processes of tribalism, tracing classical Hebrew and ancient Greek text and culture, and to show how the meanings we inherit are often smuggled in by tradition and culture. Who knows what else will start to come from this series? A Podcast? YouTube channel? Both?


← Back to the blog