I remember the feeling of guilt at such a young age for questioning whether or not the one true god really existed. Although I would say that my deconstruction journey ended about a decade ago, it truly started decades before.
For months, my Bible sat on my desk, and I didn’t want to pick it up.
Not because I thought I already knew everything in it. Not because I had become too sophisticated for religion.
I was afraid it might not be true.
If you didn’t grow up inside something like fundamental Christianity, that might sound ridiculous. It’s a book, Sean. Open the damn thing.
But I wasn’t just questioning a book. I was questioning the framework underneath my entire life. God. Eternity. Morality. The idea that suffering had a purpose. The promise that death wasn’t the end.
And whether or not I would ever see my siblings again.
That’s a lot to put on a desk and casually investigate over coffee.
I’ve written about parts of this before. But as I put together the story for the new direction of Room 9, I keep coming back to something that makes the whole thing less flattering, and more honest.
Leaving Christianity wasn’t the end of my deconstruction.
I still had plenty of bullshit left to examine. Some inherited. Some I’d enthusiastically acquired myself.
The following are the five biggest shifts in my deconstruction process. These are not five clean steps, and definitely not instructions that everyone else has to or should follow. These are just the changes that matter most to me when I look back on my boring ass life 😂😂😂
1. Christianity Wasn’t My Answer. It Was My Starting Point.
I grew up in fundamental Christianity. Eternity and absolute truth weren’t ideas I discovered after weighing the alternatives. They were part of the world I inherited.
There was a God. Life had meaning. Right and wrong had an ultimate foundation. Suffering belonged to a bigger story, even when I couldn’t understand it.
I didn’t begin by asking which worldview had the strongest evidence. I began inside one.
And I don’t want to rewrite that experience as if it gave me nothing. It gave me a framework. It gave me Community. A way to understand difficult things. Answers to questions that still matter to me.
The problem was that I hadn’t clearly separated two things:
Knowing what I believed and knowing why I should believe it.
I knew the language. I understood the broad story. I knew where the answers were supposed to land. That familiarity felt like understanding.
Looking back, the question I wish I’d asked sooner is simple… if I hadn’t grown up with this, what would convince me?
Not what would make it appealing. Not whether I could find something meaningful in it.
What would give me a good reason to think it was true?
That question eventually became unavoidable. But it didn’t start as an abstract philosophical exercise. It started with tragedy.
2. Grief Made Heaven Personal and Questioning Terrifying
My brother and sister died.
It was Thanksgiving, 1999. I was 15 years old when it happened. I remember everything about that night as if it just happened. Hearing the squeaky side door opening and closing, the mistaken sound of what I originally thought was laughter, but as I woke up, turned into weeping.
Suddenly, heaven wasn’t just something I believed happened someday. It was a promise about people I loved.
Who would I see? Would they still be the ages they were when they died? Would they keep growing? What would being together again actually mean?
I wasn’t asking those questions to win an argument. I wanted the answers to work.
I wanted to see them again.
I’ve written before about hearing that they were in a better place, and about people pointing to how many others had been saved through their deaths. Those responses became part of my questioning. They didn’t resolve the loss, and they didn’t explain how anyone knew the promises were true.
But I need to be careful here.
Grief wasn’t evidence that Christianity was false.
Someone saying something hurtful or inadequate doesn’t disprove God. A bad explanation of a belief doesn’t automatically make the belief wrong.
What grief did was make the stakes impossible to ignore.
I had to ask whether I had good reasons to believe, or whether I needed the promise so badly that I was afraid to examine it.
That’s where the Bible on the desk comes in.
I resisted looking closely because I understood that an honest investigation might not leave everything intact. I couldn’t guarantee the conclusion before I started.
Eventually, I read. I listened to debates. I talked to people. At one point, I was reading Rob Bell and Francis Chan. This wasn’t an immediate leap from Christianity to atheism. I was questioning while Christianity still mattered to me.
The important change was allowing myself to ask a question without requiring the answer to protect what I already believed.
That sounds obvious now.
It sure as hell didn’t feel obvious then.
3. I Left Christianity. I Didn’t Leave the Need for Certainty.
Here’s where I’d love to tell you I emerged from religion with impeccable reasoning and a finely tuned bullshit detector.
Unfortunately, I was still me.
I moved into being spiritual but not religious, Eastern philosophy, and non-duality. Ken Wilber. Alan Watts. Carl Jung. Spirit Science. Everything is energy. We’re all one.
I took the whole deconstructing tour.
I first took mushrooms at twenty-six, and that experience alone changed the direction of my life immediately. That belongs in my story, but it isn’t advice or a prescription for anyone else. I am not suggesting that anyone should take or needs to take psychedelics in order to change their worldview.
What I eventually had to examine wasn’t just the experience. It was what I thought the experience established.
There’s a difference between feeling connected to everything and demonstrating that everything is literally one consciousness.
One is an account of what I experienced. The other is a claim about reality.
I don’t get to skip the distance between them because the experience was intense.
And I don’t want to dismiss that entire period. I still value meditation, reflection, and examining what my mind is doing. I still appreciate the moment when something in a Taoist text clicks and it just makes you laugh.
But finding something useful doesn’t mean every explanation attached to it is TRUE.
I’d become suspicious of religious authority while remaining remarkably generous toward my own intuition.
Apparently, once the revelation was coming from inside my head, the verification department could take the afternoon off.
That was an uncomfortable thing to recognize. I couldn’t blame all my beliefs on childhood anymore. I’d chosen some of these replacements.
Leaving one framework hadn’t automatically improved my standards. Sometimes I’d changed the vocabulary while keeping the habit of protecting a conclusion.
That needed deconstructing too.
4. I Had to Examine Myself, Not Just Religion
There’s another way to make this story dishonest: tell it entirely through books, debates, and philosophical breakthroughs.
There was an actual life happening underneath the ideas.
Divorce. Fatherhood. Depression. Addiction. Questions about who I was and what I was doing with my life.
I’ve written about a period when being a father felt like the only thing I was any good at, and about how disorienting it was to lose the life I associated with that identity. I’m not going to turn this article into somebody else’s private story. What matters here is how much of my own identity I had to examine.
Those experiences don’t prove anything about whether God exists. They explain some of the human stakes, not the answer to the question.
But they mattered to the work of understanding myself.
Philosophy and psychology became part of that. So did journaling, meditation, and looking back at the people and experiences that had shaped me.
Why did certain things matter so much? What values were underneath them? Where was I avoiding responsibility? Where had I built an explanation that made me look better than my behavior justified?
That last question remains deeply inconvenient.
Being self-aware doesn’t automatically make you a good communicator. Understanding a pattern you’re stuck in doesn’t mean you’ve stopped repeating it. Having the language for your problems isn’t the same as changing them. I didn’t want deconstruction to become another impressive sounding way to avoid looking at myself.
I found out very quickly that I can criticize religious certainty and be overconfident. I can talk about honesty and still deceive myself. I can identify somebody else’s double standard while giving mine a thoughtful explanation. I think Carl Jung, like Jordan Peterson, became too obsessed with symbols, but the idea of projection helped me to turn every judgement I made on another back on myself.
5. The Biggest Change Was How I Checked My Beliefs
Eventually, I had to confront a basic problem.
I’d been convinced before. I’d held beliefs I later abandoned. So being convinced couldn’t, by itself, tell me whether I was right.
I needed something beyond the feeling.
That’s why I keep returning to this question:
What would change my mind?
Not because it magically settles every argument. Because it makes me examine whether I’m actually open to correction.
What exactly am I claiming? What supports it? What counts against it? Am I accepting evidence here that I would reject if it supported a religion or political position I disliked?
I’ve explored those questions throughout my writing on skepticism. The difficult part isn’t producing the checklist. It’s using it when I like the answer I already have.
For me, logic, evidence, and scientific skepticism became tools for that work, not replacements for a pastor.
I don’t want a new authority whose conclusions I repeat without understanding. I want to know how a conclusion was reached, what its limitations are, and what would justify revising it.
Sometimes the honest outcome is strong confidence. Sometimes it’s uncertainty. Sometimes it’s realizing an argument I’ve repeated doesn’t do the job I thought it did and the best answer is “I don’t know”.
That standard has to apply to everything that I believe.
Atheism doesn’t make me immune to bad reasoning. Neither does calling myself a skeptic. If my method only works on other persons belief system, I need to reexamine things.
What I’m Left With
I’m an atheist now. I no longer find Christianity’s claims convincing.
That doesn’t mean I’ve solved existence, settled every moral question, or discovered a replacement package with all the answers included. In fact, I have more uncertainty now than I have ever had before because I am now willing to say IDK.
I still love my children. I still care about relationships, responsibility, and reducing unnecessary suffering. I still have to decide what matters and whether my behavior reflects it. Leaving religion also meant losing a built-in community. That wasn’t nothing. Finding connection outside it has taken intention, and I don’t want to sell deconstruction as an automatic upgrade where every part of life becomes easier.
And I still wish I could see my brother and sister again.
I haven’t found sufficient evidence to say that I will. I’ve written that before, and it remains one of the hardest parts of this story.
Losing confidence in that promise doesn’t erase them. It doesn’t erase the relationship or what they meant to me.
But I can’t make the promise true by needing it.
For months, I avoided opening my Bible because I was afraid of what questioning it might change. Now, the work is making sure I don’t give my current beliefs the same protection.
I want to be able to explain what I believe, why I believe it, and what would make me reconsider.
Not once, as the triumphant conclusion to my deconstruction story, but as something I keep practicing.
Because I’ve changed my mind before.
And I’d like to remain capable of doing it again.
If you’ve questioned the beliefs you grew up with, what was hardest to examine? And did leaving them change how you decided what to believe next? Share only what you’re comfortable making public.
← Back to the blog

